tfishell: I actually came across this on Abandonia a few days ago. Do realize we would get the DOS version, and that is often considered inferior to Amiga versions.
In these cases, no. These games which appeared first on VGA PCs, and later were ported to Amiga, were usually superior on PC. Potential problems with the Amiga ports:
- The colors were not as vibrant on the Amiga versions and there'd be more color banding and such, as the graphics were transformed from PC's VGA (256 color?) graphics to Amiga's basic 32 color OCS graphics.
- Amiga floppy disks had by default lower capacity than PC (880kB per disk on Amiga 500, which most Amiga gamers had; PC games were on 1.44MB disks as I recall), and didn't always offer the option to install on the hard drive, so playing the Amiga version would many times mean constantly swapping 8 floppy disks, while the PC version ran directly from the hard drive without any disk swapping, after the initial installation.
- While the Amiga version music and sound effects were superior to the basic Adlib/Soundblaster sounds of the PC version, usually the Roland MT-32 support in the PC versions was the very best one. In some cases even the Amiga version might have supported MT-32, like some Sierra adventure games I think.
Rise of the Dragon PC version:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hb6l6jUVaco Amiga version (not that bad, but still inferior):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FKpkkQH6ZT4 The difference in graphics, see e.g. the part in the intro "There ya go, baby" where the dealer hands out drugs to the lady. Especially in that scene you can clearly see how the colors had changed when ported to Amiga. The colors are much smoother on the PC version.