The Neverhood, definitely. (Even better if you could add its soundtrack as bonus material, though nowadays it's probably easier to get than the game itself...)
The Discworld series (okay, I only ever played the second game, but will gladly pay for the other two as well).
Pandora's Box.
The Lost Vikings.
Fable (you know, the '96 point-and-click game with a stupid ending?).
Woodruff and the Schnibble (never played, but it's technically related to the Gobliiins series, would give it a try).
Super Tetris (the one with bombs. No kidding).
Don't remember what else I used to play... everything else I could think of seems to already be here (well, except maybe God of Thunder? :P Is THAT one possible to get?).
Post edited November 02, 2011 by YnK