CaptainGyro: No you're not the only one. I go through the same thing. A lot of people here seem really sensitive about any criticism of gog's releases, but I dunno I don't think being unimpressed makes someone a jerk or anything. Like you said I guess it's just personal taste. Most of the time when a new release is announced, everybody is saying "omg thank you so much this is an instabuy!" and I feel totally underwhelmed.
with that said, I am happy with the relatively recent releases of Divine Divinity, Arcanum and Syberia
JERK ALERT!
And I haven't really bought that many games here, mainly cause I don't shit money. But I do like the forums, and I did for example buy Sanitarium when it was on sale two weeks ago, I had some money in my paypal account and figured why not.