And what shall I play first? I am frozen with indecision!

It might help if we knew what the choices were. Otherwise people will just tell you to play Morrowind or something.

Play the game you're least interested in. That way, you build up to the game you want to play most. Otherwise you might get burned out early!

Open the box, play them in the order they're stacked inside.

I only ordered 1 game for myself on Black Friday this year (Skyrim) so I don't have your problem. My Black Friday haul was some tv seasons and Christmas presents. Combining what I got for my birthday, what I bought on Black Friday, and what I'm getting for Christmas I'll have something like 25 seasons to watch.

Well, my question was a bit rhetorical, but let me see, today the following arrived:
Brave (Christmas gift so I can't play it, not really the top of my list though)
D3 (it may be from the asswipes, but I got it for close enough to "free" I don't feel too guilty, and now when I complain about it sucking I can do it with authority - or hypocrisy, take your pick)
Transformers: War for Cybertron
Spec Ops: The Line (now on my console too!)
XCOM: Enemy Unknown (yes, I really do re-buy my favorite PC games when they hit "dirt cheap" on console, sometimes do the reverse too)
UFC Trainer
Syndicate

That doesn't include the digital games now sitting on my drive. Just the boxed ones that needed the services of package delivery people to arrive.

Play Morrowind. Or something. ;)

*scnr*

I think you should hold off until Barbie fashion Show arrives. ;-)

Seriously I think I would be checking out D3 or X-Com depending on the digital games you got.

Hold it, you have XCOM:EU on both a console and PC? Can you check to see if cross-platform multiplayer works?

orcishgamer has figured out how to turn toilet paper into pc games. BURN HIM, HE'S A WITCH!

You're just jealous. ;-p

Brave? Is that a game or the animated movie with the scots girl?

I often buy console or PC releases that I have on the other platform, if I really like them.

It's the video game made based on the movie. Ever wonder who buys those? People with kids buy those:)

Psyringe is a witch sympathizer.

BURN HIM!!!

Wait a minute.

You must earn the spoils of Black Friday over the dead and mutilated bodies of sub-urban moms you defeated. Not ordering it.