NamelessFragger: I actually have a Baldur's Gate II Collector's Edition I just had to grab on eBay for whatever reason (maybe because of all the love this game gets). Not sealed, and the Black Isle notepad is missing, but everything else is intact.
Duffadash: Was there differences between the UK and US version? I remember getting a T-shirt in size medium, as well as some collectible cards, the soundtrack, 2 postcards, and a poster... And a map as well I think? But not a cloth map... Also, for some reason the CD case was a german version with "Schatten von Amn" written on it. But the discs themselves were in English...
Mine is a US version (ESRB rating and all), and the missing Black Isle notepad aside, there's the color game CDs in a Collector's Edition-labeled 4-CD jewel case, a bonus CD in a paper sleeve, a spiral-bound manual that's oddly even smaller than another BGII spiral-bound manual I read once (which was roughly the size of one of those large PC game boxes), a quick reference guide, a US$10 Icewind Dale rebate form, some ad printouts for other Black Isle games (Planescape: Torment and Fallout 2) as well as some Creative stuff, an Interplay troubleshooting guide, and yes, a cloth map.
But there's no T-shirt, and I don't recall other US Collector's Editions having a T-shirt either.