It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussion (archive)GOG Mafia #4 - Nightmare of the Household Appliances(793 posts)(793 posts)
(793 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
46
47
48
49
50
53
This is my favourite topic
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
nmillar: Actually, we're not. If you're lynched, I can role block ViolatorX or vice-versa.
avatar
eyeball226: No, we are at LYLO because we don't know who the final mafia member is. If it'syou we're fucked.

Well, with Robbeasy voting for me I'm dead and we've lost. Well done guys! There'll be a night kill and then the mafia will kill the last townie in the morning.

My email address is my username @hotmail.com by the way nmillar.
sorry man - like i said it was hard choices time, I had to at least leave someone who MIGHT get us through to another day should I be wrong......theres a case for ANY of you three to be Mafia, so I made the only logical option I had.

We'll see shortly I suppose..........
Posted June 04, 2011
The "Damn you guys for making me work so late" or "A bet is won" votecount

eyeball226 - 1 - nmillar, ViolatorX, Robbeasy
nolynch - 1 - eyeball226

A total of 4 votes.

It is now twilight, standby for lynch scene. Discussion may continue until nightfall.
Posted June 04, 2011
Since I'm dead, editing doesn't really matter. I thought I ought to point out that ViolatorX's role (if the truth) is a protection role rather than a blocking role.

So the plan is for nmillar to roleblock ViolatorX and for ViolatorX to protect Robbeasy? Am I the only one who sees the flaw if nmillar is mafia? nmillar just has to kill ViolatorX and the game is over.
avatar
eyeball226: My email address is my username @hotmail.com by the way nmillar.
avatar
nmillar: If it's not you, it's ViolatorX and he'll be getting role blocked, so it's not game over.
Yes but it still could be you. In that case the game is over.
avatar
eyeball226: No, we are at LYLO because we don't know who the final mafia member is. If it'syou we're fucked.

Well, with Robbeasy voting for me I'm dead and we've lost. Well done guys! There'll be a night kill and then the mafia will kill the last townie in the morning.

My email address is my username @hotmail.com by the way nmillar.
avatar
Robbeasy: sorry man - like i said it was hard choices time, I had to at least leave someone who MIGHT get us through to another day should I be wrong......theres a case for ANY of you three to be Mafia, so I made the only logical option I had.

We'll see shortly I suppose..........
Well, the logical option would have been a nolynch. Much less to lose and the chance to gain more info.
Post edited June 04, 2011 by eyeball226
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
eyeball226: Yes but it still could be you. In that case the game is over.
Correct. If I'm mafia, then I kill ViolatorX tonight, since he can't protect himself. If I'm not mafia, then we lynch ViolatorX tomorrow after a successful Role Block.

There'd be no point in hiding the truth now if I was mafia, but I'm not and we've now got a town victory on our hands! About time too! :-)
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
eyeball226: Yes but it still could be you. In that case the game is over.
avatar
nmillar: Correct. If I'm mafia, then I kill ViolatorX tonight, since he can't protect himself. If I'm not mafia, then we lynch ViolatorX tomorrow after a successful Role Block.

There'd be no point in hiding the truth now if I was mafia, but I'm not and we've now got a town victory on our hands! About time too! :-)
Well that remains to be seen... I still want my game though. :P

I suppose if I was you and was mafia I would know that I had won and be gloating at this point. >.>
Post edited June 04, 2011 by eyeball226
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
eyeball226: Since I'm dead, editing doesn't really matter. I thought I ought to point out that ViolatorX's role (if the truth) is a protection role rather than a blocking role.

So the plan is for nmillar to roleblock ViolatorX and for ViolatorX to protect Robbeasy? Am I the only one who sees the flaw if nmillar is mafia? nmillar just has to kill ViolatorX and the game is over.
Yeah I saw that - like i said hard choices. If ViolatorX is Town and not nmillar, then he has to second guess nmillar - its a 50-50 chance. If nmillars town, we survive to another day anyway. Leaving you alive and offing one of the others gave us a possibility of automatic loss.

Only choice, really was to lynch you - nothing personal!!!...;o)
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
eyeball226: Since I'm dead, editing doesn't really matter. I thought I ought to point out that ViolatorX's role (if the truth) is a protection role rather than a blocking role.

So the plan is for nmillar to roleblock ViolatorX and for ViolatorX to protect Robbeasy? Am I the only one who sees the flaw if nmillar is mafia? nmillar just has to kill ViolatorX and the game is over.
avatar
Robbeasy: Yeah I saw that - like i said hard choices. If ViolatorX is Town and not nmillar, then he has to second guess nmillar - its a 50-50 chance. If nmillars town, we survive to another day anyway. Leaving you alive and offing one of the others gave us a possibility of automatic loss.

Only choice, really was to lynch you - nothing personal!!!...;o)
But but but nolynch! We could have made an informed decision...

Oh well, if nmillar is town then we've won... unless it's you and you're a master of disguise.

I'm looking forward to my lynch scene not having had one before.
Post edited June 04, 2011 by eyeball226
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
Robbeasy: Yeah I saw that - like i said hard choices. If ViolatorX is Town and not nmillar, then he has to second guess nmillar - its a 50-50 chance. If nmillars town, we survive to another day anyway. Leaving you alive and offing one of the others gave us a possibility of automatic loss.

Only choice, really was to lynch you - nothing personal!!!...;o)
avatar
eyeball226: But but but nolynch! We could have made an informed decision...
Nolynch could have left us in same position tomorrow easily - and i didnt realise Violator cant protect himself, so if nmillar is Mafia, he just won......arse.

I'd rather take a punt than a no-lynch any day - more exciting...;o))
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
Robbeasy: Yeah I saw that - like i said hard choices. If ViolatorX is Town and not nmillar, then he has to second guess nmillar - its a 50-50 chance. If nmillars town, we survive to another day anyway. Leaving you alive and offing one of the others gave us a possibility of automatic loss.

Only choice, really was to lynch you - nothing personal!!!...;o)
Robb, you need to be aware that ViolatorX cannot protect himself, and if he's telling the truth can only protect you. There's no second guessing involved; if I'm mafia, I can kill ViolatorX and nothing can stop me.

Survival to another day proves that I am town and ViolatorX is mafia (assuming of course that eyeball226 flips town).
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
eyeball226: But but but nolynch! We could have made an informed decision...
avatar
Robbeasy: Nolynch could have left us in same position tomorrow easily - and i didnt realise Violator cant protect himself, so if nmillar is Mafia, he just won......arse.

I'd rather take a punt than a no-lynch any day - more exciting...;o))
I can't wait for the post game breakdown. I'd also like to see the commentary thread. :P
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
Robbeasy: Yeah I saw that - like i said hard choices. If ViolatorX is Town and not nmillar, then he has to second guess nmillar - its a 50-50 chance. If nmillars town, we survive to another day anyway. Leaving you alive and offing one of the others gave us a possibility of automatic loss.

Only choice, really was to lynch you - nothing personal!!!...;o)
avatar
nmillar: Robb, you need to be aware that ViolatorX cannot protect himself, and if he's telling the truth can only protect you. There's no second guessing involved; if I'm mafia, I can kill ViolatorX and nothing can stop me.

Survival to another day proves that I am town and ViolatorX is mafia (assuming of course that eyeball226 flips town).
Yes - I've just realised that - I just hope you are town now, or I've just handed another game to Mafia
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
nmillar: Robb, you need to be aware that ViolatorX cannot protect himself, and if he's telling the truth can only protect you. There's no second guessing involved; if I'm mafia, I can kill ViolatorX and nothing can stop me.

Survival to another day proves that I am town and ViolatorX is mafia (assuming of course that eyeball226 flips town).
avatar
Robbeasy: Yes - I've just realised that - I just hope you are town now, or I've just handed another game to Mafia
Well, I'd hope nmillar would have the decency to gloat if he'd just won. :P
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
Robbeasy: Yes - I've just realised that - I just hope you are town now, or I've just handed another game to Mafia
I'd be gloating by now if I was mafia. The great thing is we're the two longest living players and we've survived to the end of a town victory! :-)
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
Robbeasy: Yes - I've just realised that - I just hope you are town now, or I've just handed another game to Mafia
avatar
nmillar: I'd be gloating by now if I was mafia. The great thing is we're the two longest living players and we've survived to the end of a town victory! :-)
Longest living in terms of game days or actual age? o.0
Posted June 04, 2011
avatar
eyeball226: Longest living in terms of game days or actual age? o.0
Number of days survived in all mafia games.
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
46
47
48
49
50
53
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussion (archive)GOG Mafia #4 - Nightmare of the Household Appliances(793 posts)(793 posts)
(793 posts)