A 34 page thread is way too long to read through - we need a way to break things down here, by developer, genre, individual game or something!

already tried... to much work

It's a mod/dev job I think - if not to break this thread up to make new threads/sections for specific suggestions as above.

well.. i opened up Excel and started to write down every single request. i came up to 400 games (page 5) until thinking... this is insane. thus quitting the program. If i cant do it. no one can
besides i think GOG staff has a pretty good idea of what games people want

This just proves my feature wish of being able to do poll threads would get lots of use! :)

We could use a forum dedicated to game requests. You know, having only "general discussion" seems a little... scarce as far as forums are concerned.
I know gog seems to be going for unobtrusive minimalism, but when a thread gets as long as the wishlist one, making it useless: no-one can read through the damn thing and still remember what they were going to request, without accidentally duplicating whatever someone else said on pages 3, 7 and 22.
Anyway, that's my 0.03gr ;)
EDIT: also, separate forum for requests would make it easier to tally exactly how many people want which particular titles, as a way for making GoG's job of delivering awesome that much easier ;)
SECOND EDIT DAMN:
THIS. This, plus a dedicated wishlist forum!

A separate site section where people will be able to indicate what games they are ready to buy is really welcome. Let's hope it will appear.