Because of the Broken Sword Kickstater I can choose one Revolution game on GOG. I hate choosing, and would prefer postponing it indefinitely (especially since I rarely play games anyway), but looks like they intend to give the codes soon, so I guess I have to.

I have Broken Sword 1 on GamersGate and Android, Broken Sword 3 on Steam and on a disc and Broken Sword 2, well, somewhere, I'm pretty sure (probably on a disc).

So it's down to Broken Sword 4 vs. In Cold Blood.

What would you recommend?

Broken Sword 4

I noticed just now that In Cold Blood is said to be compatible with XP and Vista only, not 7. That would be an issue.

If you get it on gog BS4, thats the only version that works for me, retail version has black shadows for characters (for me, ymmv), but the gog version is fine.

Okay, thanks. I picked Broken Sword 4. I'm marking sebarnolds' reply as a solution, but F1ach added some information I didn't know, so thanks a lot for that.

I think you made a good choice picking Broken Sword 4. I don't think In cold blood as aged that well

You're welcome :)

I replayed it this year and even though it's not perfect, it was a fine game (its flaws were already visible when I was released). It did not have aging problem. But then I am the kind of person who likes replaying the first Alone in the Dark game and who doesn't care about the 16 polygons that makes the main character :-)

We'll see. I remember being annoyed with the overly polygonal characters in Jedi Knight when it came out. But from the pictures on the game's page it doesn't look too bad.

I just redeemed Broken Sword 4. I like what GOG has done with this process, the way it offered me the selection.