cioran: Personally, I think it's great. One of the greatest satisfactions I've ever received in life was killing the curve in uni. It's a good feeling to know that, not only did you get the highest grade in a class, but if you have a prof unconcerned with outliers, you've also indirectly caused large swaths of the class to fail. I believe Genghis Khan said it best, "It is not sufficient that I suceed - all others must fail."
- Congrats that awesome!
Actually you raise a good point - It's been a long time since any school for me, but here in the US most classes are graded on a "curve" similar to a ranking system. The original idea was given an average class the distribution of grades should look like a Bell Curve. Your final score was based on the performance of others in your class and teachers would adjust your grades accordingly to match the curve.
Unfortunately, every teacher had their own personal version of that philosophy and thus, every teacher had their own arbitrary formula for adjusting your grades. One class I had was like Cioran's. If the highest grade was a 92/100, the teacher would just add 8 points to everyone's grade meaning you could "kill the curve" if you did exceptionally well. In another class your final grade was 10 multiplied by the square root of the raw score. (In the US scores are usually out of 100%, then converted to the GPA 0-4 point scale using an arbitrary formula that differed from school to school). A third actually normalised everyone's score to a bell curve using excel which could be very frustrating if you happened to be doing well in the class only to have your grade lowered because too many people were doing well.
I guess my beef with grading systems in the US is that they are completely arbitrary. My 3.2 in highschool, while kinda useful compared to other kids in my school, meant nothing compared to kids from other schools. I discovered that when I took some college classes back in the day and thoroughly trounced other kids who had academic scholarships (like full rides) simply because they got a 4.0 from their school because their schools boosted grades to look better to the public.