dtgreene: Just been thinking about a GPU for a desktop, and while it might not be a good time to buy a GPU, I read something that suggests this particular one might possibly be a reasonable option. The main requirement is that it be an upgrade over the current set-up (and that, of course, it's compatible).
Specs for the desktop:
CPU: Intel i5-4670 (non-k)
GPU: Intel HD 4600 (integrated)
RAM: 16 GB
Storage: 120 GB SSD, 2000 GB spinning rust
So, would the RX 550 be a significant upgrade? If so, would it be worth getting once the price drops down to, say, below $100? (The GPU originally retailed for less, so it's not entirely unreasonable for this to happen, or that some newer budget AMD GPU drops to that price range.)
Would there be any compatibility issues? In particular, are there known issues with Linux, and would I need to update my motherboard's BIOS? (Fortunately, I believe this particular motherboard can do updates via USB without needing an OS, so Windows wouldn't be needed for this.)
supplementscene: What games do you plan on playing? What's your PSU? What is your monitor resolution?
The best value is probably a second hand 4gb 580 or 570 or 290 if you can find one $150 or below.
Don't know my PSU off hand.
Display is 1080p, though I don't mind switching to a lower resolution for better performance (and I don't mind turning down settings either, as long as such a change doesn't remove important visual cues), and I do have a (smaller) 720p display available as well.
Games I play tend to be (turn-based) RPGs (playing Stranger of Sword City Revisited right now, and that's a game I would like some better performance in), and sometimes metroidvanias or 2d action games. 3d action games rarely (and would be games like Ys, Garumin, or Yooka-Laylee (note that one is not like the others)).
Strijkbout: It would help if you if you provide information for what displayresolution and framerates you're targeting for and what sort of games you want play.
Personally I would go for a RX 470 or even a RX 570 if you want to go AMD, go for the 4GB model to save money, the 8GB are overkill in most cases (you're too cpu limited for that).
Nvidia wise a GTX 1050 or 1060 would be nice, note that the 1060 has a 3 and 6GB model.
Prices of hardware are overinflated at the moment, so perhaps it's better to sit it out.
Let me also recommend
this guy, you can view a couple of videos as you can get a feel for what to expect.
Resolution: My display is 1080p, but I am willing to turn it down for better performance.
Framerate: This is a tricky question. My requirements are that:
* The game run at full speed. In particular, if the game has a concept of "physics framerate" (like Hollow Knight, which has a physics framerate of 50fps), that framerate should hold significantly.
* The graphics need to be smooth enough for the game to be playable. 30fps graphics is likely good enough, though of course a higher consistent framerate would be better.
* Input lag needs to be minimal. For a (turn-based) RPG, it's annoying when you press a button and it takes a moment to register; for an action game such lag can make the game unplayable (as was the case for Hollow Knight when this desktop still had cooling issues).