Posted August 05, 2019
dtgreene: I think you don't really understand how triggers work.
Basically, a trigger is something that reminds the person of some trauma they have experienced in the past, and causes them to relive it, which is not a pleasant experience. It's the sort of thing that, if it catches someone unprepared, can cause mental anguish. Someone might be able to handle a trigger, if they know about it in advance (hence the importance of trigger warnings), but even that might stress the player out to the point where they need to take a break. Sometimes there's just too much emotional overload.
(By the way, apparently there's a game on GOG called The Cat Lady that has a lot of heavy content that can be triggering. Has anybody reading this played it, and if so, how does the save system work in that game?)
GameRager: 1. I actually do know how triggers work or are supposed to work....I just think people overreact to way too many things and use the term like it's going out of style more and more lately. Basically, a trigger is something that reminds the person of some trauma they have experienced in the past, and causes them to relive it, which is not a pleasant experience. It's the sort of thing that, if it catches someone unprepared, can cause mental anguish. Someone might be able to handle a trigger, if they know about it in advance (hence the importance of trigger warnings), but even that might stress the player out to the point where they need to take a break. Sometimes there's just too much emotional overload.
(By the way, apparently there's a game on GOG called The Cat Lady that has a lot of heavy content that can be triggering. Has anybody reading this played it, and if so, how does the save system work in that game?)
Yes, some people have real issues and some stuff can trigger that or bring it back up, but most just use it nowadays to term something they dislike(mildly or worse) & don't want to see.
I take something like vietnam war vets having flashbacks at sounds similar to gunshots to be triggers/triggering, but not someone maybe seeing a color they dislike or a dark humor joke they dislike & getting mildly bothered by it.
2. Imo trigger warnings(if any are listed on a product) should be limited to the basics: Stuff like violence/sexual situations/su*cide or r*pe mentions/etc....anything else should just be listed in personal reviews or the like or left for a player to discover.
(Imagine if we had to cover a box in nothing but 100 trigger warnings...it'd be nonsense and the box would look like a joke)
3. I never played that game but I have heard of it.....
In conclusion: I am not saying any of this to put people with actual issues and triggers down....I just dislike people using the term so much lately to complain about minor dislikes and offenses in media/etc.
Rule of thumb: If a game warrants a trigger warning, it also warrants a save system that allows the player to take frequent breaks, particularly during parts of the game that are likely to be triggering (there should be save spots both before and after the point if save anytime isn't feasible, and there should be no boss or other action segment between the save spots and the cutscenes.
(Incidentally, this reminds me of one antipattern that comes up in some cutscene heavy games; the long unskipble cutscene followed by hard (or unfair) boss fight. Final Fantasy X has one part where you have a 5 minute cutscene followed (with no opportunity to save) by a three-part boss fight in which a first-time player is likely to die at the start of the third phase.)
(Another thought: Being able to skip cutscenes could also help with triggering issues, but while they are a feature every game with cutscenes (except maybe FMV games) should adopt, it shouldn't be the only solution to this issue.)
fr33kSh0w2012: Like me when I hear a car backfiring (sounds so much like a gunshot)
I start running and swearing and start swinging punches at random people wildly.
Screaming out "I'm gonna kill you W*g b@st@rds" because of what happend
in my High School when I was only 13 years old (just before Australia's gun ban)
Heaps of older kids had guns and knives at school so I hear a car backfire...
Then I'm 13 years old again fighting for my life everything goes monochrome
(black and white and shades of grey) and I become extremely aggressive.
My brain yells out KILL-KILL-KILL-KILL-KILL-KILL rapidly and...
My body starts to convulse with rage all because of a car backfiring.
Even annoying tapping noises Trigger me into aggression.
Maybe you have misophonia?I start running and swearing and start swinging punches at random people wildly.
Screaming out "I'm gonna kill you W*g b@st@rds" because of what happend
in my High School when I was only 13 years old (just before Australia's gun ban)
Heaps of older kids had guns and knives at school so I hear a car backfire...
Then I'm 13 years old again fighting for my life everything goes monochrome
(black and white and shades of grey) and I become extremely aggressive.
My brain yells out KILL-KILL-KILL-KILL-KILL-KILL rapidly and...
My body starts to convulse with rage all because of a car backfiring.
Even annoying tapping noises Trigger me into aggression.
Post edited August 05, 2019 by dtgreene