Agreed. Maybe not that narrow, but more narrow than currently exists. The "by series" forums work (until they break it by making separate ones that shouldn't be separate), but by genre is probably a good move. Maybe by publisher. And start retiring/merging in the existing low-traffic by-game ones.

The "franchise" forums are already pretty slow and bare, so I don't really see a need for this. It's not like your post would get flooded out. The Witcher games have separate forums because they probably get some of the highest traffic of all the game forums, this site being tied to the series in multiple ways.

Well, I feel I should explain a bit further; it'd be like a directory tree. You'd go to the according tree, and then it'd branch.