FlockeSchnee: Which is exactly the real problem here. Especially as you present this information as something like a "badge of honor". I repeat myself even though I already know that you (and those "others") either won't be able or willing to comprehend it:
mqstout: GOG has a reputation system. While it's not as thorough as reddit's, or slashdot's, etc, it's there. We should utilize it. Fairfox's reputation was properly updated and reflected: she had a HORRIBLE reputation as not positively contributing to the conversation and environment on the forums, which was entirely deserved. My down voting her disrupting the forums helped others on the forums to recognize that she was not a valuable member of the group, while also contributing to her specifically-down voted* posts being auto-hidden in those threads so others didn't have to spend effort to skip them; they were already done for them. Making it easier for actually productive members of the forums to get more out of them.
*: I do have to specify: I didn't down vote every post she made. Only when it was appropriate to do so (which was most of the time). Many were left untouched and skipped by me. I think even a couple that had some semblance of contribution to the discussion were up voted.
(I have to differentiate just in case: Of course I'm not talking about insulting posts or some such. They should be reported to a mod.)
Let's recap: 1) There is a button for it, 2) so I have to use it, 3) because other people need to be protected from having to form an opinion all on their own.
So sometimes there is no steering away from the abyss, not because of a missing button, but rather because the abyss can't even be seen.
Of course it is to your credit to at least be so considerate to not simply downvote everything "just cause". That actually gives me hope, even though it is only very little (especially considering this whole "I know what is best for everyone" line of thinking you got going there).
EDIT:
toxicTom: I have to admit, I find your attitude pretty disgusting holier-than-though. It's not for you to judge who is "a productive member" here. Also - posts you downvoted are only hidden from yourself, not for other people (unless they are deleted as spam).
I don't think that is true. I have to "unhide" posts if I want to form my own opinion and I think (not sure) there were "normal" ones among them.
EDIT2: Just checked. "Normal" (non-insulting and such) posts get hidden too, at least for me. Is "toxicity" an insult? Or am I missing a rule that post nr. 104 in this thread is violating?