Posted September 09, 2021
Breja: Oh, there is plenty of room for great and creative action films. I meant in this particular context - the kind of action Matrix did, especially in the sequels, where Neo is basically a superhero, was a lot like what we keep getting in many Marvel films and similar stuff. You could edit in parts of Captain America Civil War or Black Panther into the Matrix Reloaded, and the only way they would not blend together is if you forgot to tinge the Marvel films green.
Matewis: I'm afraid I always struggle to grasp the strong dislike for those two sequels. The action scenes in those other films you mentioned don't work for me, I think because they simply lack impact. As if there's not really anything at stake, or I don't believe/care that there is*. In this sense the attack on Zion stood in stark contrast for me compared to those films. Each time I watch those scenes I'm almost egging the soldiers on to somehow overcome the invasion. That Neo is pretty much a god likewise didn't bug me, at least initially, since I knew they only spent relatively short periods of time plugged in, and that in the real world he was as vulnerable as anyone else. That made the end of the 2nd film especially nerve wracking for me.
If I had to level strong criticism to those sequels, I'd point to the nonsensical way in which Smith possesses a human body, how Neo basically does become godlike, in both worlds, towards the end of the 3rd film (and I don't remember it being clear how), and how the final fight was a major let-down.
* then again in GI Joe The Rise of Cobra the action is also completely devoid of any tangible danger to the heroes, yet I love every second of it. At least the parts with Snake Eyes.
I didn´t like all the religious symbolisms they threw in the sequels. I mean, I could have enjoyed them if done in a different way. I don´t know, Batman Vs Superman Ultimate Edition has plenty of it, but it´s done much better. Much much better. I hated to see Neo dressed as a priest, for example.
I like what they tried to do in the sequels, but I didn´t like the way they did it.