Guess #119:
Little Big Adventure 3 / Astrid Voorhees / Norway

In for the first person to correctly identify the logic used for ordering the 14 members listed in my story above

Eeny, meeny, miny, moe

Thanks for the story:)

My pleasure.

Any combo not guessed yet? :P

If I'm not mistaken, 20 left, based on phandom's spreadsheet.

By my count there are 20 remaining. If you're looking for one to guess SMP/Voorhees/Turkey would be one of those.
Jinx. Also, I'm not using phandom's sheet, so in theory that's independent corroboration.

Do you record the post # for each entry?

Yes, though I've deleted double entries and items eliminated by clues.

Do you have an entry for post #1042?

Goodbye System Shock 3, I look forward to seeing you when you actually get released. You know, this competition has been going on so long that System Shock 3 has gone from being a pipe dream to actually being announced :o

System Shock 3 / Astrid Voorhees / Russia

I'll take care of that presently.
Sid Meier's Pirates! II / Astrid Vorhees / Turkey

18 guesses only remain!!!! 5.56% chance to win, for the next one to post!!!

I also updated my spreadsheet (after a few hours of sleep)

In for mrkgnao, even though I can't figure out the order........ Sid Meier's Pirates! II / Abigail Williams  / France

I expect this'll be my last guess, unless we've made some grave mistake. Good night.

Guess #120:
Pirates! II, Sid Meier's / Lucius Wagner / United Kingdom

In for the first person to correctly identify the logic used for ordering the 14 members listed in my story above

As badly as I want to solve the order, it just makes no sense to me. I get the sneaking suspicion it's some sort of pop culture reference which I'm too young to understand.