THIS IS NOT A TRADING THREAD!

I'd like to take Hammerwatch (received Thank you), and leave The Kingdom Elemental.

Xaxius just "walked in" and asked for a game despite his rep and walked away without anyone saying anything yet i did the same and everybody is telling me i can't get the game i asked for. My game is from the last indiegala friday bundle. It's a gift link and the game was never free.

However, the game was once offered for free. As per the OP, any game that was offered for free at a time is not permitted for the purposes this thread. To my knowledge, Xaxius didn't put up any game that was given freely.

but i didn't get mine for free like i said. Where was it i given away? I only remember greenlight and that isn't a valid excuse to say it was free

As i said , i don't understand this rule in this case.

if a game is still free, i'm agree

if a game was free and the user get it free (hard to check) , i 'm agree

if a game was free, BUT and ONLY IF it came from another source , such as this bundle, i can't consider this game acquired freely.

Basically this offer is in a "grey area" .... and if the link is valid that's just unfortunate. I though this link was checked :
http://www.gog.com/forum/general/takeonegiveone_giveaway_thread/post2481

Furthermore , check many trade lists (i know this isn't a trade topic , but it's for validating my point), you will find some traders wanting to trade some games which were free once , and are no longer free.....

Rules from the OP have been amended many times in the past if i'm correct ; so....

This rule is not about the gifter and whether he got it for free or not, but about the game, which is of very little value once it was offered for free, as a lot of people already own it. It's to prevent unfair offers and games resting unwanted in the list for good.

You will always have some people who have missed the opportunity when it was free... i didn't even know it was free ....

so for example if now i bought a redeem code of Dungeon Keeper it has so little value (at least in your point of view) it will refused as a valid offer. GOG has constantly new users....

A bought game which was once free should still have a value (less i agree) but would be still valid as offer.

The only issue , you can't really check if the game was getting free or not... and maybe the rule should stay in the actual state for only this point. But for the actual offer since it's an Indie Gala link & it's obvious the game wasn't free for the person who bought the bundle -> so it's unfortunate for all people who are in the same case ....

That's just my thinking.

I see you deepdig or justaquickie or moonlight_ or walli13 or Jimmke or catboxiee or unknownLOOTER ..... and many many others.....I see you....

i have received darkout so that's verified as gone and a pm is going out to you for the hammerwatch and Monaco is now avalible

Can i leave something else then? Is paranautical for steam? If so, i'll leave Cogs instead.

I've received Hammerwatch (Thank you Xaxius!) The Kingdom Elemental is still available.

I'll take Monaco and leave Planets Under Attack! (steam)

Thanks!

I received Syberia 2 (Thanks letsmaybeLP92!), Bastion (Steam) is available.

i take bastion and leave teleglitch (humble link)