Niggles: "City Game Studio is inspired by marvelous games like
Game Dev Story
Game Dev Tycoon
Software Inc
Sim City
Mad Games Tycoon"
Anyone tried Game Dev Story/Tycoon and Mad Games Tycoon?.
I've played Mad Games Tycoon (and Game Dev Tycoon, which I'm guessing is the most-commonly-played of these, so I'll use it as a point of reference). Mad Games Tycoon rapidly eclipsed Game Dev Tycoon for me. Pretty much everything is more customizeable. Custom office furniture? Yup. Custom rooms, built like it was The Sims? Yup. Tons of options for game genre, aspects of the game, publishers? Yup. Hire as many people as you want? Sure, just make sure you have places for them to work.
It also looks nice. But mainly it's a more in depth version of Game Dev Tycoon, in a way that makes it more immersive.
Game Dev Tycoon itself was, IMO, the OG of this genre. It was fun back in its day, but it's a fairly linear progression between a set of prefab offices. Mad Games Tycoon - and from the looks of it, this game - let you customize your company to your liking.
Software Inc is another jump forward. Whereas Game Dev Tycoon and Mad Games Tycoon make it fairly easy to make money as long as you don't quickly over-expand, Software Inc is more challenging, at least on Hard, which used to be the default difficulty. It models the network effects of the market, so e.g. people are more likely to buy a Total War game because they're familiar with the franchise. It also has categories other than games. Overall it's my favorite for software in general, it's just so well polished, and scratches that tycoon/business simulator itch a little better with its difficulty. But if you want to focus on games in particular, Mad Games Tycoon is the one I'd recommend among those I've played. It has a lot more options for game-specific technologies and genres.
The challenge for City Game Studio is going to be differenting itself in what's becoming a crowded market. From the screenshots, it looks pretty similar to Mad Games Tycoon, which makes me wonder why I should pick it up as well.