Bookwyrm627: ...

Dessimu: Anyone missing?

Bookwyrm627: Also, there's an interesting implication in your statement: if they work well together, they are likely the same alignment. My mind provided this expansion: If they know they are the same alignment, then logic indicates they are likely to be wolves. What do you think of this implication?

Dessimu: Can someone slap me in the face to wake up a bit?

Bookwyrm627: By casting a net, I mean he is being active. Active players can make mistakes, and we want wolves to be making mistakes. An active wolf will be searching for reasons to lynch townies or protect wolves. If I'm choosing between two players that ping neutral (or undecided), and one is significantly more active, then I'm more inclined to help lynch the less active player.

We've had multiple scum teams from time to time. It isn't so frequent that it gets assumed from the outset, but it isn't something to dismiss out of hand either.

Bookwyrm627: I wouldn't know; my experience with both of them is limited to this game.

Also, there's an interesting implication in your statement: if they work well together, they are likely the same alignment. My mind provided this expansion: If they know they are the same alignment, then logic indicates they are likely to be wolves. What do you think of this implication?

Bookwyrm627: No. It was a straight up comment about how you get really into a game, and perhaps a subtle request to manage your energy so you don't burn out by late game (assuming you survive that long). As near as I can tell, I'm actually on your team this time around.

Bookwyrm627: Something else came up, or I'd have left it longer.

bler144: Can tickle you if you like.

DragonSushi: was [Brasas] seriously suggesting no lynch? ... What would you have hoped for from the [reactions]?

Dessimu: Typing feast #2.

Note that I have no computer around here, now, so I wish and can't go through all of the posts of a few individuals (Nachomamma, Tammy, Bookwyrm, Lifthrasil and Lxamyakxim) and make better insights. Well, technically I can, but that would be pain in the fingers.

...

• SirCrimsonFox has made more flavor related jokes than comments on issues at hand. That is what "cahoots" meant in this case. As in flavor-like cahoots what with all the animals in the hats. Bookwyrm made a case which sounds about right. So all I can say now - suspected.

• DragonSushi is apparently able in giving content. There is little of it and partly understandable but without any explanations or indications as to why exactly, that just seems like staying shut on purpose. Suspected.

• Stanari - had same problem as above. Lack of content to work on. Could be either mafia or town, though because of a few lines leans more towny than scum. Neutral.

• Nachomamma is like me in my first game and Bler now combined. Acts in towny way, but I put as neutral almost just because of the entrance. I need to reread him.

• Tammy looks towny. It even rhymes! Reminds me of how cristigale plays.

• Cristigale always looks towny. At least for me. I think there are a few certain things she does when being mafia, but I won't tell those and I don't see them either. She makes strong insights on her own for her own. So, towny.

• Bler I like. As a sort of a compliment, I especially like how he described yogsloth and RWarehall. Feels right and amusing. As scum he really plays more chaotic. Now he is honestly involved and knows what he is doing. Town, most certainly. But should not be followed blindly.

• Trentonlf is always saint. Even when he is mafia. I expected him to be more talkative now, but there is not much to talk about, other than smart assumptions of people. I feel like trentonlf is now observing people and is being on his guard against the new players. But this I know: Day 2 and further on he will sniff out any scum slip (as town) and lock onto it. Still, being more silent than usual - neutral for now.

• Brasas is one strong persona. He plays very strong as town, don't know his scum play. Seems to be poking players and not without a reason. We played together resistance game here and Brasas guessed correctly almost all scum team very early on. So what I learned is this - his early suspects should be looked very closely at. Looks towny.

• Docbear leans town more than scum but only based on my gut feeling. I played a few games with her (her, right?) and I feel like as mafia, she would give lead to buddies and follow them. Now she plays her own game. Neutral as of now.

• Lxamyakxim I have also at the neutral camp. Need to reread him, I don't remember all posts. But with vote on no-lynch, I have no problem with. Mainly because we all considered it one way or another by pointing out dead girl-lynch villagers nonsense.

• Lifthrasil I have always suspected in general. I mean, every time I am town and Lift is in the game, I treat him as mafia from beginning until proven otherwise. This time is no exception. Nothing solid, so neutral. Needs to be reread.

• Yogsloth I would expect to roleplay more. He is too calm this time around but hey - can't be a madman all the time. Plus, he probably is exhausted from MU games. I only know he needs to be observed from all angles at all times. Neutral.

Anyone missing?

• Agentcarr, good luck. In general, falls somewhere between neutral ans scummy because of nearly no reflection on the content and that little that has been made - chosen in a very peculiar way.

• RWarehall, welcome to the game. Nothing to base opinion on, so that's that.

Really, anyone else left not mentioned?

Anyone at all?

Me?

I am still waiting for that silver and you all seem to be uninterested in giving me work.

Of the few suspected:

Vote: SirCrimsonFox
No lynch is a waste of time.

...

Going to sleep now. If I had computer with all the nice addons, I would go through all posts of the select few and make insights with quotes. To do so now - too much of a pain.

As per request to sign our stuff:

Nathaniel (Nathan) Smith - village smith in my name and profession.

TammyTown: Does [bler] when scum have a tendency to post a lot without contributing and so you went back to check if his receiving town reads was naive?

Nachomamma8: My expectation for the game is that we are supposed to know that no-lynching is something that we are supposed to do, then there would be some sort of hint that flavor meant something; "let's no lynch because the flavor hasn't given us a reason to yet"

drealmer7: clarification:

"NO-LYNCH being at L-1" post was meant to TROLL you all (or at least, troll my fellow GOGlins) - I added the "(if L-1 exists)" to remind that it is basically stated in the rules that there is no L-1 because there is no real hammering - at least I thought that much was clear and so I thought the joke would be clear - so I want to make that much clear now

bler144: Not sure what to make of it. But two players seem to be very deliberately teasing the same thing, one slightly more than the other but pretty hard to miss. Spotted a thread of the pattern thinking it might be accidental/coincidence and looked back and looked closer and ...wow.

bler144: Side note, but I was really surprised no one corrected/clarified/expanded on my "GoG player summaries." Surely I didn't cover everything of relevance and/or nothing I said couldn't have an alternate POV?

Dessimu: • Trentonlf is always saint. Even when he is mafia. I expected him to be more talkative now, but there is not much to talk about, other than smart assumptions of people. I feel like trentonlf is now observing people and is being on his guard against the new players. But this I know: Day 2 and further on he will sniff out any scum slip (as town) and lock onto it. Still, being more silent than usual - neutral for now.

Brasas: 5 - Bler | Marie
snip

Dessimu: • Lifthrasil I have always suspected in general. I mean, every time I am town and Lift is in the game, I treat him as mafia from beginning until proven otherwise.