darthspudius: Well, that's a very narrow minded way of thinking of things.
KISS has had their share of quality albums (the first record is killer!), Alice Cooper is a legend for a reason, King Diamond again, legend for a reason (Abigail!). Ghost have been churning out a lot of great stuff recently. Very subdued compared to most bands these days which is such a refreshing change. I'd rather watch a band who puts effort into their appearance and stage presence than a bunch of long bearded people standing like they have sticks up their asses for 2 hrs.
Well, it's not more 'narrow-minded' way of thinking of things than thinking that 'broad' way of thinking of things is the best and only way of thinking of things.
And I can't get into arguments like '
being legend for a reason'. Legend to whom and by whose reason?
Quorthon for instance is a 'legend' to some, but it does not make his music and lyrics better. His knowing of Norse lore and its interpretation is on schoolboy's level, his music is not 'epic' at all (just listen to some of
Manilla Road, or better 'From the Fjords' album by
Legend, and it's 1979!). And as for dirty sound, there were
Venom and
Hellhammer already.
Iron Maiden are ten-times bigger 'legend' than
Bathory but it doesn't make their music better. Harris is a very mediocre composer (not to say worse), McBrain is a very mediocre drummer, and Dickinson just annoyingly yells on one note (but he blossoms as a vocalist in his solo works, just because Harris' monotone and dull gallop doesn't give him room enough). They just make run-of-the-mill kinda-heavy-metal for everybody.
For everybody doesn't necessarily mean
good.
Manowar are 'legends' too but in fact they are just the Kings of Posers in the Kingdom of Rubber Inflated Quasi-Mucho-Superheroes.
David DeFeis though being completely freaking mad is much more epic, sincere and true.
KISS are a pure distilled glam-commerce-teenager-show-oriented shit. They may having made a few decent guitar riffs but the glam-commerce shit overweighs, sorry.
King Diamond would be nobody without Denner/Shermann and La Rocque. And his whelp wailing spoils even their brilliant music, especially in Merciful Fate. If you wanna wail - take a couple of lessons from Halford.
Cooper is rock-theatre, and not metal at all (though he wanted to be treated so just to be fashionable), so he's beyond my sphere of interest. And as a rock musician, he doesn't stand in the same row with Blackmore or Hendrix.
Ghost had rather promising debut disk but that's all. Now it's just disco-Batushka sort of show-shit.
So 'being a legend' or 'having a zillion of Youtube views' has nothing to do with the quality of music.