It was three years ago, but the game only got 4 votes. So this is my call to vote for the game Shine.

https://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/shine

Let´s "flash mob" that thing. A thousand votes should be sufficient for the beginning. :)

Do you have more data on this? Like a mobygames page, Wikipedia entry, website?

Here is the mobygames page:
http://www.mobygames.com/game/shine

Unfortunately I couldn´t find any more infos about it except this one video on youtube. It´s a rather unknown game. I played it once many years ago, but it was a pain to get it working on Win XP. It needs Quicktime Player for playing the ingame videos, but I didn´t get it to work.
All I can say is that it is a really crazy and surreal game - and it´s almost impossible to find out what to do, if you are not crazy yourself or have a good walkthrough.
I can´t compare it to any other game. It would fit perfectly in Gog´s catalogue.

EDIT: Ah, I see, they compare it to Shivers, 7th Guest and 11th Hour.

It works! The votes for Shine reached the double digit level!!! 10 votes now. Keep it coming!

Those review ratings don't do it a lot of favors...

Yes, but a lot of old games got bad reviews in their time. Still I think that they are worth to be preserved and played again. Some play really well when you know what you can expect. As a person who loves games I have great tolerance regarding old games. Isn´t this the reason we are all here at Gog? :)