Microfish_1: if i switched to trent, as a way to get a lunch without a systematic roleclaim on D4, would you join me?
Yes, I would. Trent is still a valid lynch candidate, as I stated repeatedly, and your argument that his flip would clear up some confusion is true too. He remains someone who acted scummy before Today and was correlated with yogs.
Microfish_1: Hmm. Lift has been present much of toDay, while Joppo summarizes and disappears. would the remaining scum or two fade or try to misdirect?
JoeSapphire: If it's Lift, he would try to misdirect. He certainly would not fade.
That's true. I only fade if I'm swallowed by RL.
JoeSapphire: Questions raised by the statement: "the missing kill in the Night before is easily explained by SPF's death. Probably he was the one who was supposed to perform the nk, but Joe was faster for some reason."
- what was the reason?
- is that a standard rule?
- has there ever been an example of this being the rule on gog before?
Yes, there has been an example of different kill speeds on GOG before. In a game I ran (the scum-only Mafia conference). It's not standard by any length. Usually simultaneous kills both succeed. However, defining a list of action sequence is norm. Like: Roleblocker beats NK and so on.
However, your point is moot since I was in the meantime proven wrong by reported word of Mod. (check posts #1185 and my reply #1187)
JoeSapphire: I think Lift's behaviour this Day is certainly fitting with scum lift -
You always say that. Sometimes you're right and I am scum even though the majority sees me as Town. But this time I have to disappoint you. This time you're wrong. Which means this time I'll get to tell you in post-game: I told you so! ;-)
agentcarr16: @ all - Isn't Miller a policy lynch? Vote stays.
Usually yes. But policy lynches aren't as written in stone (for me) as for example the 'Lynch all liars' tenet according to which you should be dead since D1. What I mean is: policy lynches of certain roles (Miller, PGO) are more of a guideline and in this case I think it's better to try to actually hit scum than to remove a Miller immediately. We have several Nights available before us. So we can re-visit Pooka tomorrow, if necessary and if the game isn't over by then.
OK. I see that after Joppo's claim his wagon justifiably dissolves. Maybe the claim is true.
unvotus Joppo @Joppo: if you really are a Tracker, I suggest that you check on one of the unconfirmed but suspicious players that claimed a role that doesn't move. Neither Vanilla nor Miller are supposed to be going anywhere. So if any of those moves, it's a straight scum proof.
And since one of the hidden PRs is now out in the open, I might as well claim too. Since several players were unhappy with me not claiming. I am Hannah Abbott from House Hufflepuff and I'm a Vanilla Townie.
OK. Let's lynch someone. Preferrably not me, but you do what you think is best. For now, I'll follow Micro and go back to trent. But if necessary, I'll switch to Consul.
vingardium leviosa trentonlf
