Posted July 06, 2015
Cavalary: Basically, if you take it as a method of crowdfunding, typical early access is a single-tier, fixed-value-for-fixed-perk, (more or less) unlimited-duration crowdfunding campaign.
If you take it as a purchase, it's... Well, it's not a purchase, it's a ripoff.
So depends how you approach it.
GOG did go above that though, blending preorder and early access, or basically giving early access as preorder bonus.
About the game being out in the open for those who don't want to fork out any money before actually knowing the details, devs that just want that can give away a large number of copies to reviewers and people who make let's plays, with no NDA or strong arm tactics to make them paint them in any better light. So that's no excuse.
That sounds like a reasonable analogy overall. While I have more fond thoughts towards clear crowd funding efforts such as those on Kickstarter, I share my resolution to not buy them until they're completed and released on either GOG.com or Steam. One game that I'm very interested in for example is Kingdom Come: Deliverance, which is heavily crowd funded and been in development for quite some time now. Looks like an excellent game so I hope they are able to complete it and release it officially some day and I'll get to play it. If you take it as a purchase, it's... Well, it's not a purchase, it's a ripoff.
So depends how you approach it.
GOG did go above that though, blending preorder and early access, or basically giving early access as preorder bonus.
About the game being out in the open for those who don't want to fork out any money before actually knowing the details, devs that just want that can give away a large number of copies to reviewers and people who make let's plays, with no NDA or strong arm tactics to make them paint them in any better light. So that's no excuse.
While I like the idea that crowd funding exists, by personal choice I am not a crowd funding participant myself largely for the same reasons I wont loan money to a friend or relative that is 2 months late on their car payment or rent who promises to pay me back 2 weeks from now when their magic cheque comes in the mail. Instead, my preference is strongly do the opposite, which is to say I prefer to pay money later (via credit cards for example) for something that exists right now in it's full officially released final product state. Hmm.. I guess... um.. does that make me a ...
Crowd spender? Hey... that's catchy, I like it.