It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #70: The Shelter - A Fallout Game(1574 posts)(1574 posts)
(1574 posts)
Pages:
1
25
50
75
81
82
83
84
85
105
This is my favourite topic
Posted October 25, 2020
Replied to Catte and Bucktooth:
(Nothing in this post is a vote)
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

avatar
my name is vaughlte catte: Either it'd be another huge coincidence or it'd be because btg was somehow involved in the death.
That's how I feel about it right now, but I have been drinking wine so what do I know?
Sounds good.

So let's say Buck "coincidentally" hides behind the next NK, without telling us who it is.....how would that make you lean them and what would your response be?

(i.e. voting, etc)

++++

@Bucktooth: Again, if you're town coward, scum would be essentially "playing russian roulette" if they continued to target you once your role was known to them.

But I agree with Catte.....keep it quiet(your hiding choice), and we will see what we will see on D4.
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
GymHenson: While yer here, what do you think the odds are that a claimed town coward would believe keeping their hiding target for the upcoming "night" was a worthwhile thing?
avatar
my name is vaughlte catte: Well... let's say he really is a town coward. We're already suspicious of him for having hidden behind both kills so far, if he says who he's going to hide behind it gives the mafia a chance to frame him. Provided his shield isn't one of them, they can either safely target him or just directly kill the person he's hiding behind. Either way we'd have another night where he's hidden behind the NK. If he keeps it a secret then the mafia wouldn't be able to engineer that situation without the risk of him hiding behind one of them. If we still end up with btg's "shield" dead then it'll be a lot more meaningful because the mafia wouldn't have realistically been able to engineer it. Either it'd be another huge coincidence or it'd be because btg was somehow involved in the death.
That's how I feel about it right now, but I have been drinking wine so what do I know?
The way I see it there are three ways to move forward tomorrow IF tonight's kill does not flip scum:

1. You all lynch me tomorrow, and find I was telling the truth

2. You all decide to believe me, and we start looking into who would has shown signs of fascination with killing me.

3. The NK is town and NOT the person I hide behind. I have been upfront with providing my hide targets the next morning and I don't plan on stopping now. Granted this will also assume that people believe me when I name my targets after the fact.
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
bucktoothgamer: 1. You all lynch me tomorrow, and find I was telling the truth
Or we maybe choose to lynch you tomorrow if you somehow "hide behind" the NK again, in case you are scum.

BTW I had a "wacky" idea(more half serious musing really): You could message me your hiding target....and I could choose your message to be the one I carry on N3.

(Don't mind me...I come up with crazy ideas when tired and on pain pills o.0)
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
my name is vaughlte catte: ...
@catte

Just thought of something. Since you're Loud, catte, you can prover yourself by failing purposely. That way we know you couldn't do the kill. Or doin another action that can be confirmed by the recipient, if you think of any.

This way, either 4 scum or you not scum.
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
ZFR: by failing purposely.
how he does this??

avatar
ZFR: That way we know you couldn't do the kill.
unless scum can act & kill in the same night


Catte says he's got a plan. I'm looking forward to whatever it is
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
ZFR: by failing purposely.
avatar
JoeSapphire: how he does this??

avatar
ZFR: That way we know you couldn't do the kill.
avatar
JoeSapphire: unless scum can act & kill in the same night

Catte says he's got a plan. I'm looking forward to whatever it is
Invent something that has low chance of succeeding. Lift gave the odds at one time.

Invent being an Innocent Child.
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
ZFR: Invent being an Innocent Child.
come on dude, if that was his plan now it looks like he got it from you!
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
ZFR: We dont do scum/town lovers on GOG.
avatar
bucktoothgamer: Well that answers that then. Even so, my understanding of such roles would be that it would be counter productive for joe to buss dedo if that is what they were.
Sorry, as catte said, I was messing. That kind of Lovers did happen exactly in a game I hosted. Joe was one of them.
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
bucktoothgamer: Well that answers that then. Even so, my understanding of such roles would be that it would be counter productive for joe to buss dedo if that is what they were.
avatar
ZFR: Sorry, as catte said, I was messing. That kind of Lovers did happen exactly in a game I hosted. Joe was one of them.
No worries, guess even my text to sarcasm meter fails sometimes.
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
ZFR:
hey your Catte trap only works if there's 4 scum
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
GymHenson: BTW I had a "wacky" idea(more half serious musing really): You could message me your hiding target....and I could choose your message to be the one I carry on N3.

(Don't mind me...I come up with crazy ideas when tired and on pain pills o.0)
to quote joe...

avatar
JoeSapphire: come on dude, if that was his plan now it looks like he got it from you!
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
ZFR:
avatar
JoeSapphire: hey your Catte trap only works if there's 4 scum
why?
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
JoeSapphire: hey your Catte trap only works if there's 4 scum
avatar
ZFR: why?
I'M GLAD YOU ASKED!

the requires a Telepath in order for trentonlf to have communicated the message to Catte.

As we know Catte is a Crazy Inventor, and not a Telepath, then there must be a fourth person if Catte had received the message.

*bow*
*flourish*
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
ZFR: why?
avatar
JoeSapphire: I'M GLAD YOU ASKED!

the requires a Telepath in order for trentonlf to have communicated the message to Catte.

As we know Catte is a Crazy Inventor, and not a Telepath, then there must be a fourth person if Catte had received the message.

*bow*
*flourish*
Good point. Though strictly speaking my trap would work with 3 Mafiosos, so long as one of them can't prove his role is not Telepath.

However, can't Mafia have Day Chat without Telepath? All we know about Telepath is that if he exists, Mafia have Day Chat that stops when he dies. But there is no guarantee in the role list that Mafia can't have a regular Day Chat if Telepath doesn't exist.
Posted October 25, 2020
avatar
ZFR: However, can't Mafia have Day Chat without Telepath? All we know about Telepath is that if he exists, Mafia have Day Chat that stops when he dies. But there is no guarantee in the role list that Mafia can't have a regular Day Chat if Telepath doesn't exist.
I suppose it's possible
Pages:
1
25
50
75
81
82
83
84
85
105
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #70: The Shelter - A Fallout Game(1574 posts)(1574 posts)
(1574 posts)