GymHenson: And I hope this isn't a scum!Bucktooth admitting that they're scum in a subtle way, to point at later when the game is over. o.0 :\
Most everything you said till this line was in tune with my own view on things. I was almost starting to worry what happened to GH I know. I'm glad he's fine :)
my name is vaughlte catte: Not sure if letters arrive during the night or at dawn when all the other night actions are resolved, but if it is earlier then he might have been able to tell them even without a telepath.
From my experience the letter comes just before the start of the day where actions are likely locked in.
GymHenson: (It's just the more silly messages that get sent, the less chance a serious one will get through :))
But a serious one did come through and it was sensitive Town information that reached scum eyes.
GymHenson: (i.e. people seemingly trusting the newbies to be town more than others in general)
People don't trust newbies to be more Town than others. Newbies tend to get more leeway when they do something that can be an honest mistake of a Townie who doesn't know better or [calculated] foul scum play.
GymHenson: But why would a anti-town neutral admit to such a role? It'd be akin to saying "lynch me!" imo.
Catte can't not admit though. Even though bucktooth allegedly didn't know he could have identified Catte's role, he did expose him in a way where Catte can't claim otherwise without putting the two of the in a "one or the other" predicament. Whatever Catte is in terms of alignment he has to come out.
GymHenson: Imo it's more likely Catte is truthful, and is either a neutral that's helpful to or at least not harmful to town.
I agree with this as it doesn't make sense to me that scum!Catte would risk getting exposed like that for a mere investigation (obviously he won't protect a non-buddy) when they are already down one member.
ZFR: Today I investigated Joe on the off chance he's a third party killer. He isn't. Joe is neither a killer third party nor a target. Meaning he's Mafia or Town.
You got healed and was allowed to investigate in the same night?
bucktoothgamer: 3. If my PR role was nerfed after I claimed, why do they keep giving me opportunity to use it?
If you are what you say you are your role in itself keeps working as intended. Whether or not others would fall for it is a very different topic. It's weird how you don't seem to understand why scum likely wouldn't touch you with a ten foot pole while there is a chance for their kill to backfire.
JoeSapphire: What do you reckon dedo? having had a similar experience in the last game where town were confirmed by their powers and the net closed in
IF you were scum this game and got caught, say, shooting blotunga in the head for example OR WHATEVER, would you approve of the town deliberately going easy on the rest of your team? Or do you think they should pull out all the stops and aim for the high score?
I wouldn't approve of it as everyone is playing in the same game and could have rolled into any other slot.
JoeSapphire: 10. dedoporno - first vote on trent, but jokey vote, and also first to remove it. maybe scum??
Can you show me where I said it was a jokey vote? I voted for a very specific reason even though it was flimsy (but still good enough for the start of D1) and had additional reasons to stick to it. I only unvoted because Trent's claim didn't get countered by anyone.
ZFR: Counterpoint: He did it to "prove" he's Hider.
Are you referring to Coward? What's Hider?
Engerek01: Last night I changed Joe to male. Sorry about that.
NOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! All caught up.
@GH, bucktooth does look like a "safe" policy lynch but I'm also interested in who the other scum is (I believe it's pretty safe to assume that it's unlikely there were more than 3 of them at the start). Also, what if bucktooth is what he claims? Although, as soon as I wrote this I remembered that we have the numbers in our favor and barring some crazy stuff we can afford to mislynch Today and Tomorrow before we get to MYLO.
ZFR: The proof is in the fact that no one counterclaimed that they got infected instead. So unless Mafia purposely didn't use Infection on N1, I'm non-Mafia. Good point. 
