Posted August 04, 2015
Enebias: Ouch. It seems this was quite the letdown... thanks for sharing your opinion, as I was eager to know more about this apparently very promising title. What you described is basically the sum of everything I wouldn't want to see in a similar game, so I appreciate the warning!
On the other hand, I'm still pretty interested in the first one: may I ask you what the strongest point of the original Breach & Clear are?
Yes, you may. If you know what Frozen Synapse is like, then B&C isn't that much different. The game consists of three types of missions: Terrorist Hunt, Bomb Defusal and Escape Plan. There isn't really "a campaign", just these missions that are laid out in six (IIRC) locations. Gameplay is entirely turn-based: you command four soldiers, give them separate orders, and when you're done the game advances time a few seconds. You need to have your guys shoot from cover, because otherwise you're gonna get killed, but you also want to make the fastest time possible in order to get the best rating, so there's definitely a risk-and-reward feel to it. Spreading the soldiers around is generally a good idea so that you can flank opponents, so there's a nice tactical feel in the game constantly. If you like Frozen Synapse, there's a fair chance you'll B&C too. It's a little rough around the edges, but since it's a small budget game with a reasonable price tag, it's acceptable. On the other hand, I'm still pretty interested in the first one: may I ask you what the strongest point of the original Breach & Clear are?
So basically:
+ Feels tactical, your actions matter (unlike in Deadline where you can just keep your guys in a cluster)
+ Good turn-based system: plan your actions and see what the outcome will be
+ Easy on the wallet
= Semi-ok customization; you can name your characters, choose their portraits and assign their roles, but on the negative side there aren't that many new weapons to unlock, just a handful. Also, all level-ups are a simple "now you have 5 more HP" sort of upgrades.
- No real campaign
- Not as polished as Frozen Synapse
Check out some YouTube gameplay footage. I've found that's the best way to see if I'd enjoy a certain game.