Andy_Panthro: I never understood why reading a book makes the movie stupid, can't both coexist and be good in their own medium? I saw A Very Long Engagement 2 days ago and enjoyed that movie as much as the book.
Its the changes between the book and film in this case that annoy me.
In the majority of cases I'm not bothered, this was just a specific example of changes I disagreed with.
Blade Runner is a good example of deviating from the source material.
Well, in this particular case, both book and movie should never have been released to the public. Shitty writing is shitty writing. But yeah, sure, sometimes sometimes. Sometimes the movie's better, sometimes they're equal, it's just that most often the adaptation pales in comparison. It's especially rare for an adaptation that deviates from the source to be better, because the changes are often for the worse. Often a change from original to cliche Hollywood dogshit.