rtcvb32: I guess to say, a number of gamers today are spoiled and don't know how far we've come, and aren't interested, they just expect things to look better and be better each year. As such a number of franchises don't change much (
if at all). With that i'd say i would love to see a lot more PS2 quality of games, at least in terms of hardware requirements and complexity, while models and textures could be probably double of the PS2 (
but not nearly close enough to be PS3).
Tell me about it. I'm exactly the same. I would love to see stripped out games. More fun, less flash. Like you said about Quake or Doom. No blur effects, no "realistic graphics", just a platform that would provide a lot of fun by gameplay.
For me, "realistic" it's opposite from "better". I just played Quake 1 for last two weeks, as i got it in a bundle, and oh god, how fun it can be, so fast paced and it does not even have free look. I think that "modern mechanics" like head shots and realistic backgrounds really messed up first person shooters. I don't want to feel like i'm in an real battlefield, or else i would have enrolled into army. I want to feel like i'm on an battlefield on steroids.
Not to mention character movement. In older games, when you stopped running, you pretty much stopped running. On modern games we have "inertia" transposed into character movement. Something like "well, you don't go 20-0 km/h in real life, you shouldn't do that in games either". Yea, good thing that i can kill 200 armed soldiers with a pistol all by myself, but we're getting realistic on physics laws that, even if they are true, they are annoying for having fun in a game.
And regarding our problem. Technology exists. It would be possible to make a game that could range from low graphics to high and that could range between requirements on an much wider areas that now. You could make Fallout 4 to look like Half Life 2 by adjusting the settings, but to also have high-end possibility. You can even sell them separately. High-def DLC in addition to the base game. The problem it's at hardware sells. Majority of gamers would play Fallout 4 looking like HL2 instead of buying a new graphic card. But when you don't have a choice, but you still want to play the game, you will buy that graphic card.