ElTerprise: I haven't played Torchlight II (yet) but from what i've heard it's better than the first in every aspect. Why do you found Torchlight dull? I'm curious because i quite liked it.
I found Torchlight 1 to be too repetitive with very little storyline. The levels were just the same ones repeated again and again. The enemies were the same, there was little to no real story to it, and the location became a but dull and samey. I don't know really, it just bored me. I loved Diablo 2, but I think that game had a much better storyline and had enough variation to keep it interesting. Torchlight 1 for me was just level after level of the same thing with no storyline to keep it interesting. I liked some parts of the game, the cool female character dual-wielding guns, the cute little pet that saved so much time selling items (there was also too much low level loot in the game). I liked the cartoon style to it, and at first I enjoyed it. but after an hour or so it just became dull.
moonshineshadow: I played the first two acts of Torchlight 2 with a friend. And it was nice just slashing tons of monsters while talking. But the story was not really interesting and the fights were most of the time not exciting. So for the last act which I played alone, I could not even bring myself to finish it.
But perhaps you should get some other opinions, I know there are many people who liked it :-)
*goes to check what other games are included in the bundle*
If it wasn't for the fact you said you don't like horror games I would have suggested Outlast. I had so much fun playing that game. A strange amount of male nudity, but some very interesting characters and a fun game. I liked Doctor Trager's character, the voice actor and character were great. Even if he was evil. :-)