Beyond Good and Evil is really good and original. For me it was one of my top games. top and original design, top story (one of the best of a videogame), great music, large world (for a 3D game of that time)
I never played Psychonauts so I don't know how good is it.
Prince of Persia is really a good game but it's not original like B G&E.

Personally I'd go for Beyond Good and Evil, but I would also wishlist PoP...


Now, I have to wishlist Psychonauts XD

Yarrr Psychonauts be one o th' finest geims made by that crazy corsair Schaffer. It be full o' laughs an funny moments and it shivers me timbers right off. But it be better ta play it wit' controller. An' th' meat circus level be all manner of frustratin' like trying ta eat a hardtack wit'out teeth!

But it be one o' th' best geims out there ye can plunder fer yer booty!

I wishlisted Beyond Good & Evil and Psychonauts since so many people liked it. They would serve well to my "always own 20% of GOG games" policy.

If you really liked the old Tomb Raider games I'd say Prince of Persia.

They did patch it to make it easier. You may have played it post-patch.

Most likely post-patch then. I remember dumping well over an hour into the final level, and never beat it. Ended up watching my roommate who also played the game on the original Xbox, and you pretty much have to make every single jump and run and going up to the top perfect or you start over, maybe 1/10th of a second room for error. Not unbeatable, but a little too punishing for me.

Or maybe I'm just that good.

Tell that to rtcvb32. >_>