Sorry for the necro-thread but have since played some of the games and would love to possibly get some new perspectives as well...
Breja: Company of Heroes was fun, if you can get past building tank factories right on a WWII battlefield. It's the kind of stuff that I don't mind in something like Starcraft, but in a more realistic setting it bothered me to no end.
Yeah, that has been one of the biggest reasons why I have COH and COH2 but still haven't loaded them up. Battlefield engineering is fine but building tanks in the field just feels like a bridge too far. Still, people rave about these games.
Dray2k: Buy Men of War: Assault Squad GOTY on GOG or Man of War: Assault Squad II on Steam which also has Steamworks support and also slightly better gameplay. Company of Heroes 1 and 2 are also fine games but I only really enjoyed the skirmish modes in them and Men of War is much better than both CoHs.
Yes! The Men of War Assault Squad games sound great.
I think I'll be playing Faces of War sometime soon... and then move on to the Assault Squad games
Am currently playing through Sudden Strike 4, and although I feel it's not great, I'm enjoying it. It got me to buy the Blitzkrieg games and to look at Sudden Strike 3.
I hate to say it but this WWII RTS search has now got me looking at WWII grand strategy and turn-based strategy as well! Ugh
CMOT70: And if you want the most authentic experience of all, then the Close Combat series.
I've had issues with top-down games, but with Close Combat The Bloody First being 3D I may take the leap! Definitely interesting.