It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
In pool of Radiance..what's the general preference
For + weapons...the 2 handed with no shield or one handed with a shield for the lower ac?..i tend to do some.of both so was curious as to.the general preference once you have enough items to do either
Post edited November 10, 2019 by Dargo1620
It partly depends on how many pluses you have on your 1H, 2H and shields.
Also, against human sized or one square enemies the difference in damage potential is not that big.
In practice I usually go for 1H + shield, with a 2H as backup weapon.
Post edited November 10, 2019 by PetrusOctavianus
avatar
Dargo1620: In pool of Radiance..what's the general preference
For + weapons...the 2 handed with no shield or one handed with a shield for the lower ac?..i tend to do some.of both so was curious as to.the general preference once you have enough items to do either
There are certain points in the game where, at least in my experience, you'll have access to two handed swords +2 as well as at least one ring of protection +1, while your best longsword is +1. With that in mind, I go for the two-handed sword every time, because the drop off in your armor class isn't as big a deal as the bonus to hit and the additional damage you can do to larger enemies.

That said, I have a fighter using a +1 shield and +2 mace who reliably does decent damage and rarely gets hit. I'm sure there's a sweet spot that balances the tradeoff between damage and defense, but I've done pretty well with the two-handed sword approach.
I carry both, as the OP said. Longsword for one-square icon monsters, two-handed sword for two or four-square icon monsters.
Damage for smaller monsters is 1-8 (average 4.5) longsword, 1-10 (average 5.5) two-handed. So two-handed usually isn't worth the AC change, especially if you have a magic shield.

Damage for larger monsters is 1-12 (average 6.5) longsword, 3-18 (average 10.5) two-handed. At that point it becomes a risk-benefit tradeoff.