DF1871: For this achievement you have to solve the NCR's problems:
After completing the first two NCR quests, (Things That Go Boom and Kings' Gambit), head to Hoover Dam and talk to Colonel Moore.
You will now have to deal with the Great Khans, the Omertas, Mr. House and the Brotherhood of Steel. Your last objective will be to protect President Kimball, now report back.
How you solve the problems should be up to you, if the solution you choosed is a problem your questgiver will point it out. Making peace with the Brotherhood shouldn't cause problems.
If you still don't get it might be a bug and sometimes earlier decsions cause problems...
Here is a nice decription, complete with decisions that cause problems and known bugs:
https://fallout.gamepedia.com/For_the_Republic,_Part_2 Edit I: removed typos
I were try 6 times even try by kill everybody in Brotherhood of Steel and still nothing