Hey, just bought Devil's Dare and I'm trying to configure the controls but something is messing up. Every time I try to bind a key it immediately binds to Joy2 Axis4-. I first tried to use a controller and found if I held the key down and then tried to bind it worked. However I'm trying to bind the controls for player two to the keyboard, but it still always binds to Joy2 Axis4-.

I am using a ps4 controller with a program to make it recognized as an xbox controller, but even if I unplug it to bind player 2 it still binds wrong. I have also tried lifting my mouse so the game can't pick that up. Anyone know how to fix this?