I mostly stay away from news, trailers and anything that could spoil a game I think I will buy, so can't be sure of what some of you refer to when they speak about Cyberpunk being shortened.
It doesn't seem to be the concern of the thread creator though? What I read is that he\she may prefer a mainquest with consequencial branching and increased reactivity to the choices offered to the player, rather that a game filled with not necessarly interesting side quests at the expense of the main quest(s)'s complexity and options.
The comparison between Witcher 2 and 3 is valid here, because each represent a different minset of games development.
That being said, W3 being open world and having a lot more of side quests don't automatically make it a superior game.
But on the other hand, nothing is forcing you to hunt every monsters contracts, treasures, and others sides things.
So W3 being too long is not a valid thing to say in my experience, if anything, the main quest is too short and very underwhelming compared to W1 and 2. A shame when it was supposed to be the most interesting, with Geralt having his memories back,(or so the game tell us) and objectives that are actually his concern for a change.
But it's not the witcher's forum, so I just keep the two different 'models' of games in mind.
W2 (or W1 for that matter) aren't 'lesser' games to W3. They treated their main quests a lot better than the underwhelming W3. But like I said, the latter isn't mandatory longer, especially if you consider that in universe, it make absolutely no sense to 'wander and explore', let alone chasing every side things, or even to help some of Geralt's 'friends'. You can choose that at least.
To conclude, Cyberpunk is, to me at least, a different beast in the sense that, (for what I know?), it doesn't have the weight on it's shoulders to have (much?) established characters, universe and such through books or otherwise?
So I can start fresh and just enjoy, my only expectation is a interesting and potentially great game, regardless of it's 'model' or the like, I can just start fresh and see. Hm, actually I expect (with a moderating hope), that the game will surprise me and who knows, maybe merge both discussed above models in a successful way.
Post edited October 24, 2020 by Revan1