Posted April 28, 2015
crumb24: If I remember correctly, the first time I played, Imoen and I went to where Gorion fell right away. I literally followed the roads and signs to go straight to the Friendly Arm Inn afterward, because I had just done everything the green monks in Candlekeep had told me to do, so why not do what the starting order was. Granted I had played about half of Baldur's Gate 2 before I started BG1, so I knew a little bit what I was doing from that. I eventually had to go look for help online then, because Imoen and I couldn't beat the mage at the Inn. After I read, I went back to an old save and picked up Xzar and Montaron to help beat the mage.
I tell you this, because I think what Not Jabba suggested is a perfectly reasonable thing to do your first play-through. On my first play-through, I did not look at a walkthrough right away because at the time I still had dial-up internet and did not have a working printer. Sometimes, I think you're just contrary for the sake of it.
Hickory: First, and foremost, I never said what NotJabba said was not reasonable. I said that closing with an enemy when you're a squishy mage is a recipe for game over. I was making a distinction: he/she advised closing with the enemy. That is a sweeping statement, and in most cases will get you killed. Game over. I tell you this, because I think what Not Jabba suggested is a perfectly reasonable thing to do your first play-through. On my first play-through, I did not look at a walkthrough right away because at the time I still had dial-up internet and did not have a working printer. Sometimes, I think you're just contrary for the sake of it.
Secondly, to claim I am contrary just shows you either don't read correctly, or you have a reading comprehension problem. We (NotJabba and I) have two perfectly valid opinions. Just because I state mine does not mean I am contrary. All opinions count. Yes, even yours.
Back on Topic. If you don't want to die frequently, I would advise against playing as a mage your first time through. There's no point in making it harder for yourself than it already is.