Well... did you take into account the 74 votes for Jedi Kinght: Dark Forces II?
Jedi Kinght :)

Because the world isn't perfect.

sounds better. =P

Some people are also voting for games which were already XP/Vista compatible when they were released.

And games that haven't been released yet.

And games that only exist on consoles....

And games that don't even exist.

Those just haven't been released yet (if they ever will is another matter) :-P
And MMO's, I doubt GOG will set up servers to run the games on, especially without a monthly fee.

That doesn't matter; quite a lot of existing GOG titles didn't actually need any fixing to run correctly on modern OSes. The difference with the GOG versions is that they are DRM free and include additional tweaks and fixes where possible.

I'd like it if we could scrub the idiotic content out, games that dont exist for example. There's a lot of EA stuff in the wishlist as well, which isn't necessarily bad (Crusader series).
One thing that would be handy is if games have been entered a few times, merge them. Look at Ultima 7 for example.

It's been done, partly:
But although Star Wars: Dark Forces 2: Jedi Knight and Jedi Knight: Dark Forces II were merged (to the latter title), Jedi Kinght: Dark Forces II and Star Wars: Dark Forces II: Jedi Knight still remain as separate, and there may be other copies of the same game I haven't seen, and the same situation exists for a truckload of other games (just using the previously stated game as an example)... it seems to be a largely manual process, so it's probably up to us to inform the team of each game so they can correct it.
Until they update it to better manage duplicates, this'll have to do.
An idea would have to be for the user's to be able to group 2 or more games and say "these are the same" on the wish list, the devs would be able to then see that "oh, entry A has been grouped with entries B, C and D by 50 users, and with B and D by 30 users ... yeah, it seems to be various misspellings of the same game, we'll group them".

Good selection there. If you can have it giftwrapped and sent to my address I'd appreciate it.
Karl

updated on 13 April 09
Here is the new list... Enjoy ;)
11. Grim Fandango ..............................942
12. Deus Ex ....................................908
13. Thief II: The Metal Age ....................890
14. Dungeon Keeper 2............................834
15. Baldur's Gate ..............................832
16. Thief: The Dark Project (Thief Gold)........827
17. Arcanum: Of Steamworks And Magick Obscura ..810
18. Dungeon Keeper..............................806
19. Star Wars: X-Wing Vs. Tie Fighter ..........792
20. Baldur's Gate II: Throne Of Bhaal ..........768
21. Star Wars: Tie Fighter......................766
22. Maniac Mansion: Day Of The Tentacle ........759
23. Baldur's Gate: Tales Of The Sword Coast ....753
24. Syndicate ..................................638
25. Jedi Knight: Dark Forces II ......614
26. Thief: Deadly Shadows ......................608
27. X-COM: UFO Defense (UFO Enemy Unknown)......592
28. Dungeon Keeper: The Deeper Dungeons ........582
29. Star Wars: Dark Forces......................580
30. Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic......569
31. Crusader: No Remorse........................565
32. Crusader: No Regret ........................551
33. Wing Commander IV.......................549
34. The Elder Scrolls: Daggerfall ..............534
35. Syndicate Wars..............................533
36. Star Wars: X-Wing Vs. Tie Fighter: Balance Of Power Campaigns...520
37. Mechwarrior 2 ..............................518
38. Icewind Dale II ............................500
39. Icewind Dale................................499
40. Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic II ..498
41. Wing Commander: Privateer ..................496
42. Blade Runner ..........................................491
43. Wing Commander: Prophecy (Wing Commander V)..486
44. Sam & Max: Hit The Road ....................482
45. Master Of Orion II: Battle At Antares ......482
46. Aliens Vs Predator..........................470
47. Little Big Adventure 2 (Twinsen's Odyssey)..469
48. Star Wars : X-Wing Alliance ................467
49. Wıng Commander III............................460
50. Homeworld 2..........................................457

not a bad game in the lot...
though the big gap between 10 and 11 does show how they really need to update the way the wishlist works.