Red_Avatar: I actually bought the game to try that (I liked it originally anyway) and it runs just fine, without zero fiddling.
It is certainly possible GOG has fixed it later, just like they should. I still have it installed on Windows 8, so I'll try this:
- See whether the current installation still fails to run.
- See if it is possible to run it with e.g. running the exe directly, as someone suggested
- Uninstall it, and download&install again the latest GOG version, whether it works this time.
timppu: Also, Gothic and apparently a bunch of other games have visual glitch (window borders showing in full screen mode), but there are some manual instructions how to overcome that.
Red_Avatar: That's all rather vague. Personally, I play a lot of oldies and found no big difference between the two - in fact, I think I didn't find a single game that refused to run with no workaround. I'd still like some concrete examples so I can investigate them.
I don't think there was anything vague about the Gothic example. I read about it earlier (from Arkose, I think), and faced the same issue last June when I installed Gothic on Windows 8. But I also found the instructions how to overcome the issue, which worked for me.
Again, it may be possible GOG has fixed that too afterwards (ie. applied those workarounds needed in Windows 8).