Elmofongo: I never had any problems being a Warrior/Tank in Dragon Age mabye for my first RPG to play as something else I wll go with Dragon Age.
orcishgamer: Well, let me be clear, it wasn't "too hard" as much as it was... stupidly boring, at least for myself. At least with the other classes you have something to do... I mean if you want to, if you're a mage you can throw a heal and watch your party do most of the work if you're feeling lazy, but that doesn't prevent and Earthquake and "cloud kill" (whatever it was called) combo if you're feeling active.
Really? I though that Dragon Age did a relatively good job of making "warrior with shield" a viable and fun option, much better than a lot of other games. Certainly mage is the most versatile option, though.