anjohl: Protip?!?! LOFL, thanks, now I know to ignore you.
Suit yourself. Although generally this kind of statement carries more weight if you don't then go on to immediately respond further to the person you just said you were going to ignore.
anjohl: My argument does not rest on whether or not DRM's prevent piracy, it rests on the fact that publishers will not release profitable games WITHOUT DRM, which leads to my conclusion that Goo is the least instrusive option for both publishers and consumers.
Which is to say that with regards to publishers GOO is snake oil, just like pretty much every other DRM system. As for intrusiveness, different people have different concerns and find different things intrusive. Thus saying "this DRM system is the least intrusive out there" is a pretty meaningless statement, as it only says how you personally feel about the DRM system, which frankly is something I'm guessing not many people care about (same goes for how I personally feel about various DRM systems). What
is of use is a clear explanation of just what a DRM system actually
does, and if you feel it's fundamentally different from other DRM systems an explanation of just
how it is different. From there everyone else is free to decide for themselves just how intrusive they consider that DRM system, and just what effect, if any, it will have on their purchasing decisions.
anjohl: I have several published articles to my name about DRM and internet privacy/ownership rights, trust me, I am about as anti-DRM as anyone who isn't just an ararchist piracy advocate.
Good for you... I guess. Although this discussion wasn't really about being anti-DRM, it was simply about trying to understand what a specific DRM system does, and since the claim was being made that the DRM system was fundamentally different from the other systems out there, just how it was different in light of what it does. Although since it seems that particular line of discussion has run its course and is now simply poised to degenerate into petty bickering, it's probably best to stop derailing this discussion and let it get back to being about Torchlight.