Crosmando: I liked SH4, I thought the whole "Room" idea, with the portal in the bathroom to different "worlds" was really novel, it worked up my imagination a bit. Though in terms of horror, it wasn't really scary, SH1 is scary, being alone in the dark with that flashlight in the hospital or the streets probably won't ever be beaten in a horror video game again. Especially since all horror games these days have abandoned 2D fixed perspective with pre-rendered backgrounds, and become utterly crap as a result (cough Resident Evil cough). Also Downpour is going to be fully 3D, and you can bet it won't be scary as a result, get ready for boring flashing images and grinding on monsters for hours.
Edit: does anyone remember that level in TR1 with the giant rats?
In fact fear 2 did one school scene so good that it reminded so much about silent hill (well there were no pink bunnies) Just in first person. They made that good. i wished a lead pipe then.
Giant rats? Doesn't ring a bell just the thousand times when I was axed or spiked.