Posted February 23, 2014
TStael: English in USA has never been a hegemony, because USA is not a national state as such. German came very close at the original vote, and so might have French, had they not had anti-Huguenot policies in place in the colonies.
SJThreepwood: Most Americans were of British descent at the time of the revolution. Subsequently, English has always been the dominant language. It wasn't the only language spoken -- but it was seen as the most important.
"The original vote" that you mention is actually a myth:
German Language Myth
German Language Myth
But then again, I think "dominant" here means similar as to what has passed in the British Isles with the Celtic languages; until the very recent times when promotion and revival is being attempted - hopefully successful, but who knows.
I do not think this type of domination is anything to be proud of; nor do I think the USA is impaired in any way if "America the Beautiful" is sung in native; or any other language for that matter.