Yup.

People who judge a game's price on GOG by comparing it to a price on another service should take into account that (a) GOG sells the game DRM free, which the other service might not, and (b) GOG often sells the game with extras that the other service might not offer.

That said, I'd regard some games on GOG as overpriced even after taking this into consideration. However, I don't see any reason to complain. GOG and the publisher make an offer, and I as the customer am free to take or leave it. There are many excellent offers on GOG, especially when sales are considered as well. For the games that are priced higher than I'm willing to pay for them, I simply hope that their price will drop sooner or later.

Your missing the bottom line. They make more money. Getting a game on a Steam sale is the best thing that can happen to an indie dev.

The sheer amount of games being sold on a sale offsets any "lost full price". In DD there just about no "fixed costs" and the steam/gg/whatever fee is usually a percentage of the sale price. If a game that is reduced in price by 75% sells five time more copies than it would if not, then they make a profit. And usually it sells ten times as much as it would otherwise.

And, apart from all the money, the game gets more know, more people will at least try it and the company will get more well known. If a dev can't handle the success, it's their fault. Princec is like of of those guys that complain about higher taxes when they earn more money. In the end you have a bigger profit and that counts.

Again, if a game is sold for 75% off at a Steam daily deal, that isn't bad for the dev, it's good for them.

Duuuude...
It comes with the (amazing super fabulous) soundtrack, and the game is really good as well.
Also, it's totally less than ten dollars already ;)

Fair. It's mostly the first game that I think is way overpriced. I personally think they should bundle 1 and 2 together, but lowering 1 to 5.99 would also be ok with me.

I say o you master of Orion

get both 1 and 2 for 6 bucks or for the steal of a a price at $10 you to can own number 3
please tell me that makes sense as a pricing scheme

ps I'm not saying that master of Orion 3 is over priced after all I decided not to buy it for 83 cents in a GoG sale

It depends where do you live and what's your financial status. Here in Poland, you can easily buy food for a few days for $10. :P
But no, I am not saying "overpriced". I am just not buying if the game does not suit me.

Anything above $5 is too expensive for me.

My idea of an ideal date is the dollar menu, in that case I've dated my best friend a thousand times.

When it comes to video games, $5.99 is my limit :P I'm poor

Edit: Can't believe I can't spell 'date'

MoO3 is a special case. If GOG paid everyone ten bucks for downloading it, it would still be overpriced.

Gothic 3 Forsaken Gods is the really special case. If GOG paid everyone ten bucks for downloading it, it would not only be overpriced but also a crime against humanity. As it is the number of people getting tormented with it will be minimized and that is a good thing.

Yep, I'd have to agree this has greatly slanted expectations. People don't complain about 10 dollar XBLA titles, for example (10 dollar DLC is a bit steep, but compared to the spate of recent 15 dollar DLC that's even starting to look cheap).
No one actually "buys" MoO3, they get it as part of a bundled weekend deal.

I think this, is the main argument by people who say so usually. Although qualitatively the game may well be worth 9.99, a lot of people will simply go for the cheaper option in a lot of cases. And with more and more retailers starting to carry the same games as Gog is, the more pronounced this problem will become.

I tried this.. they turned me down :(

You haven't been reading if you haven't seen this criticism. The expectation that games will be on sale for a deep discount 1-3 months after release may have drastically lowered release day sales figures on the PC. If true it would be a small wonder that devs would primarily target the console platforms.
Agreed, HoMM 2 is the best HoMM, hands down.