rampancy: Bump.
So Prometheus is out (apparently released last week). For those that have seen it, what are your thoughts? Good? Bad? Mediocre?
Good, you won't hate it, doesn't live up to the hype. The problem is there is more than one narrative, due to Scott finding a more interesting story along the way and downplaying the Alien aspect, this has the unfortunate effect of showing just how fucking boring the narrative about the Alien portion of the film is. Also, since there's 2-3 narratives (depending on how you look at them) there's 2-3 endings as well, which annoyed some folks, though I thought they were all necessary.
So basically, the film probably would have been better and far more interesting had it had nothing at all to do with Alien.
Two of my nitpicks were: 1) the film progressed the narratives way too fast at some points, leading me to believe large portions of the story were cut or (worse) never even filmed, I hope it's the former because there very well could be a 3 hour director's cut version later on, and 2) there's a couple of things you deduce are happening or have happened in the film, then the film spoils the moment by blatantly stating "X happened" in a really obvious and insulting manner, I could have been drunk out of my mind and picked up on it before; this happened at least twice.
As for the 3D, well much ado was made about him having filmed in 3D and while the 3D didn't look bad, it wasn't spectacular either, most of it was muted, but present. Scott also neglected some of the really impressive 3D shots he could have gone for (such as a pan around of the Prometheus landing). I didn't spot any shots that had been framed specifically for 3D which leads me to believe he didn't need to do 2 shots of some scenes and nothing in the 2D version will be different or jarring (3D shots can be incredibly jarring in 2D, especially since 3D often doesn't follow the rule of thirds). So go, with whatever you feel like. A single concession stand item in the US will run you more than the 3D glasses, so if you're on the fence sneak in your drink or candy bar and pay the premium, if you don't generally care, you won't be missing anything you'll regret.