I'd still like to see an end to the war and possibly a new one after the emperor is reborn & possibly man unites with some races to confront some other problem and another war begins...see? Main storyline would advance, yet the war would carry on and everyone would win someway.
Dude, again...stop acting all egotistical. If you were just a fan you wouldn't be raging so much over someone knowing less about the universe or wanting change in some way to it.

There is nothing egotistical about it. You haven't read anything so how can you claim the setting is stagnant??

The War will never end GR, if someone did win the amount of rage from other people who collect other armies worth hundreds of hours and money in preparing them would all kill themselves. I know people who would probably do this :)

*headdesk* Again that's the SETTING not the story the STORIES happen in the setting.

Oh so now it's a terminology "attack"...watch next you'll insult my grammr.

And yes, the war never ending for how many eons and the god emperor never being reborn, just stuff shoehorned in to the universe to keep people buying fancy figurines? Yes, i'd bloody well clal that stagnant.

Differing opinion. Funny thing, I though you were just trying to push buttons and see folk attack you as it makes you look like a "victim" here. No. I will have different opinion and I think you do this for some kind of kicks.

It is BS debate as it makes no sense. It's like deciding to clone a human with and ass where head usually is and say it improves greatly as now you can talk out of your ass and that would be solution to the problem. Nope.

As to the third one, you are not a lesser fan. You are not fan at all. You are just picking battles for funsies as you do in other topics.

Ah, the human-alien alliance... *facepalm* That would work with Emperor reborn wouldn't it? You know, all with that whole xenos war and total hatred. Read up more before you open your mouth, this is prime example of a troll you are.

The war can't end, I can say this is true for the Eldar. They can't field any of their planet killers because they are so far away. If they were beaten back no one would make the jump to conquer them because they literally have a gigantic space armada of epicness. So they can just sit there and train units and send them through the warp forever.

1. And you're free to it, but I like to debate and sometimes my opinion is the unpopular one and it looks like i'm doing it for kicks when 90% of the time i'm not.

2. And imo the fans saying the universe is ok the way it is and never needs to be changed is also sounding like that.

3. No i'm not picking battles and am a bit of a fan.....stop making opinions out to be facts and trying to get me hot under the collar so I start slinging insults so you can discredit me further.

3. Not trolling, so stop trying to discredit me with ad hominem attacks and either debate me seriously here or leave.
It could still shift focus though, alliances formed betwen man and alien, a divison in the imperium(albeit just a splinter breaking off to fit the storyline well), etc.

This just displays your total lack of understanding of the Warhammer 40,000 universe. You seem to think the characters in the story are the Emperor and the Eldar and the Chaos Gods. The characters are the small people the ones fighting the endless wars across the universe. Ibram Gaunt, Eisenhorn, Gabriel Angelos these are the characters in the story not some corpse on a Golden Throne who is little more than a plot Maguffin. You have fallen into the trap many people do when the first come across WH40K thinking it's like Star Trek or Star Wars with one giant story with larger than life heroes. It's not. Read and understand or continue in your ignorance confident in your opinion it's up to you.

I again see no problem with the stories but the main storyline above them all. With some changes many new substories would be come possible. And it could even just be on offshoot and the main old universe could continue for older fans.

Yet I can't have my opinion I guess because I don't have all the codexes and read all the wikia entries and play all the time, I guess.

Also not ignorant...opinion isn't fact.....and being a fan still means you should be open to opposing opinion in a more civil way.

There is a difference between an informed opinion and an uninformed one. Mine is an informed opinion you have the chance to be informed but you refuse.

The Emperor is no more a character than Jesus is and I doubt he will return either.

I am informed enough. In fiction one doesn't need to know everything to form a subjective opinion on it.

Also regardless of if he's just a figurehead/plot device the main storyline hinges partially around him...If he was reborn alot could and would change.

Really...you make it sound like i'm stating facts and getting them wrong and not just making a few suggestions and offering opinions.

And that can be pretty much turned around at you. Maybe pretty much everyone here is bashing you for couple of reasons a) they are not you using your other account(s) b) they just dont' like you c) you are talking so much shite claiming it's an opinion and unpopular one as well d) I will ad hominem your ass as much as I wan't, my right to do so.

Oh we are all serious here aren't we lads/ladies? That's why we are discussing GR's opinions!

I guess ignorance is bliss and also a shield that lets you just talk out of your arse. And thanks for the PM. I will refer you to point d) of the first part of this post.

Now that the whole "civility" that comes from you of all people - one who start fires under the guise of civility is just insulting. Go away.