I have reviewed the votes on Adaliabooks on Day 1 during his lynchwagon. I'll ignore Viteks RVS vote on him, and start with the first real vote, Robeasy's.

Post 142 -- Robbeasy pressure votes for adaliabooks over the spaceship/train thing. He unvotes in post 283 after adaliabooks clarifies his actions, presumably satisfied with the response. I have already stated I think this was a pro-town use of pressure voting, and my opinion has not changed. I believe the entire "Do you see what I getting at" (forget exact wording) post is a red herring, and I'll need to look through to see who first brought that up on Day 2.

Post 397 -- Robbeasy again votes for adaliabooks. Were he scum, I am not sure he would do this. Adaliabooks still had a lot of heat on him, so why be the first to renew pressure. Perhaps had Robbeasy re-added his vote after a wagon got going on adaliabooks, I would feel different, but, in this case, it seems pro-town.

Post 408 -- Mrkgnao is the second vote on adaliabooks' wagon. It was a very quick vote on adalaibooks after Robbeasy placed his again. Had adaliabooks been town, this might be a little scummy, but since adaliabooks flipped scum, it changes matters considerably. Adding a second vote on someone with heat on them during Day 1 has a very good chance of ending up with them lynched. If scum is going to bus a team0mate like that, I would expect at least a couple more votes in the wagon. Mrkgnao seems pro-town.

Post 410 -- Yogsloth makes the third vote on adaliabooks' wagon. Everything I said about mrkgnao applies to this vote, only more so. Regardless of Day, the third vote on someone is the kiss of death in my experience. It is possible to escape a lynch after the 3rd vote, but it usually involves a parallel wagon gaining more traction or a believable role-claim. Since adalaibooks' was the only person with any real heat on them at this point, I don't think he stood a chance. Yogsloth's vote placement makes him the most pro-town player in the wagon.

Post 418 -- Adaliabooks votes for yogsloth. Either adalaibooks was still trying to avert his imminent doom, or he was trying to add confusion to later days by voting for a scumbuddy as he went down. I am stongly leaning towards the former, given yogsloth's placement in the wagon, as well as other reason I noted in my reads post Day 1.

((After this point, I think it was inevitable that adaliabooks was going to get lynched. Folks were ready for the Day to end, and adaliabooks was the obvious target. For this reason, everyone else more of a shade of gray, whether or not they are on or off the wagon. Scum could have easily voted for adaliabooks here, guilt-free, or sat on the sidelines to let town do their dirty work.))

Post 468 -- trentonlf is the 4th vote on the wagon. Dead smack in the middle of a wagon that has become almost a forgone conclusion.

Post 469 -- I am the 5th vote on the wagon. I actually started my post in which I voted for adaliabooks prior to trentonlf's post, but it hardly matters. I think the 4th vote is essentially the same as the 5th vote in this context.

Post 480 -- Dedoporno is the 6th vote on the wagon. This might be a big deal under other circumstance, putting smeone to L-1, but given the circumstances, I don't think it is a tell one way or the other. It could be town certain of scum, or it could be scum getting in bussing vote.

Post 491 -- Trentonlf pulls his vote, returning the count to 5 votes. It could be scum pulling his vote on a scumbuddy, hoping a false-claim might work (adalaibooks was already hinting he wasn't vanilla). Or, it could be as he said, he could have been waiting for everyone to chime in. Both are plausible.

Post 504 -- flubbucket is the second 6th vote. 'Nuff said.

Post 516 -- dedoporno pulls his vote, returning the wagon to 5 votes. This might be suspect, except ...

Post 535 -- dedoporno re-adds his vote.

Post 559 -- CSPVG hammers. This says nothing, in and of itself, as someone would have hammered eventually, I am certain. He does give a veritable laundry list of reasons he is hammering, though.


That leaves Sage103082, Vitek, DarkoD13, HijacK, and trentonlf offt he wagon.

trentonlf -- He brought the vote count to 4, then got off when it hit 6. Like I said above, this could have been scum trying to give a scumbuddy a chance to dig himself out of a hole, or it could be a town player making sure everyone has a say before a hammer vote. I read this as slightly scummy.

Sage103082 -- in post 529, she does suggest that adalaibooks is making a last ditch effort with his claim. She doesn't make a vote, nor does she elaborate on what alignment she believes adaliabooks might be. Could possibly be scum fence-sitting a little; unwilling to condemn a scumbuddy, but wanting to get a post in confirming suspicious of a possible false claim. Or, it could be Sage over-thinking it (but this could apply regards of her alignment). My read here is a little scummy.

DarkoD13 -- in 550, much like trentonlf, he says he will hammer after CSPVG posts. It is unfortunate that CSPVG hammered before he could make good on his promise. I think he would have hammered, but it still would have been nice to have confirmation. Regardless, he is fairly neutral to me; I can see valid reasons for both scum and town to behave has he did.

Vitek -- In post 519, he says he agrees with lynching adaliabooks, but he doesn't make a vote himself. He instead asks a lot of pointed question, withholding his vote until the are answered. I don't like his mild fence-sitting, but I do like his questions. His actions seem pro-town to me.

HijacK -- In post 354, HijacK gives reasons why adaliabooks isn't scum, but then states that he sees no advantage to keeping him around. This smacks of trying to have it both ways, or, in other words, fence-sitting. This seems scummy to me.

-----------

I know some of my points have already been discussed Today. I'll most likely end up addressing them later when I make a post on everything I think is notable that has happened on Day 2.