Posted November 06, 2014
As you may or may not know, GOG has again subtly changed the format of its game pages, thereby breaking MaGog’s database update feature. I expect to be busy with it for at least a few nights. I don’t want to feel that I am somehow holding us back, so I am taking some time at work to share my updated readings. I am posting only a gradient list with basic arguments as I don’t have at the moment time to quote other posts in full. Please do not fault me for that. If something is not convincing, just ask and I will attempt to clarify.
The events surrounding CSPVG’s wagon and claim have forced me to re-evaluate my stance about quite a few people. I concentrate on these changes.
Executive Summary
================
- CSPVG moved to strong town
- Vitek and DarkoD13 moved to neutral
- HijacK moved to tend to scum (voted)
Gradient List
==========
Strong Town or Tend to Town
======================
- CSPVG: Pretty much confirmed unless counterclaimed.
- dedoporno: No change.
- yogsloth: No change.
Neutral
======
- DarkoD13: His assumptions about the mafia roles had me worried, so I feel a need to re-evaluate. Still he remains the most townish of the neutrals.
- Sage103082: No change.
- Krypsyn: No change.
- Vitek: His handling of the CSPVG affair has been impeccable and I find his posts about it convincing. I do not fault him for voting on CSPVG. His arguments were pretty reasonable, even if I disagreed with them. After the claim, he acted exactly as I would expect a responsible townie to act. On the other hand, I have not forgotten the points raised before by Darko, dedo, Krypsyn and myself, so he’s just back to neutral.
Tend to Scum
===========
- trentonlf: No change, but feeling guilty about it because of his latest plea. Still, there’s his L-1 vote post. I really want to believe him.
- Robbeasy: No change. I must admit that I do look forward to learning what the name of the ship he’s piloting is.
- HijacK: At some point in day #1, I decided to give him the benefit of the doubt and not compare his behaviour to that of yestergames. I ended day #1 with a rather firm feel of towniness about him. Then came the posts where everybody can be either town or scum. Then came the active role fishing. And finally came the whole series of posts surrounding CSPVG from his vote argument onwards, each raising more alarm bells than the other. Were it anyone else, I would be practically certain he was scum, but with HijacK I can still envision a case where he just might be playing an anti-town game all for himself. Nevertheless, he feels scummy enough for me to vote.
VOTE HijacK
The events surrounding CSPVG’s wagon and claim have forced me to re-evaluate my stance about quite a few people. I concentrate on these changes.
Executive Summary
================
- CSPVG moved to strong town
- Vitek and DarkoD13 moved to neutral
- HijacK moved to tend to scum (voted)
Gradient List
==========
Strong Town or Tend to Town
======================
- CSPVG: Pretty much confirmed unless counterclaimed.
- dedoporno: No change.
- yogsloth: No change.
Neutral
======
- DarkoD13: His assumptions about the mafia roles had me worried, so I feel a need to re-evaluate. Still he remains the most townish of the neutrals.
- Sage103082: No change.
- Krypsyn: No change.
- Vitek: His handling of the CSPVG affair has been impeccable and I find his posts about it convincing. I do not fault him for voting on CSPVG. His arguments were pretty reasonable, even if I disagreed with them. After the claim, he acted exactly as I would expect a responsible townie to act. On the other hand, I have not forgotten the points raised before by Darko, dedo, Krypsyn and myself, so he’s just back to neutral.
Tend to Scum
===========
- trentonlf: No change, but feeling guilty about it because of his latest plea. Still, there’s his L-1 vote post. I really want to believe him.
- Robbeasy: No change. I must admit that I do look forward to learning what the name of the ship he’s piloting is.
- HijacK: At some point in day #1, I decided to give him the benefit of the doubt and not compare his behaviour to that of yestergames. I ended day #1 with a rather firm feel of towniness about him. Then came the posts where everybody can be either town or scum. Then came the active role fishing. And finally came the whole series of posts surrounding CSPVG from his vote argument onwards, each raising more alarm bells than the other. Were it anyone else, I would be practically certain he was scum, but with HijacK I can still envision a case where he just might be playing an anti-town game all for himself. Nevertheless, he feels scummy enough for me to vote.
VOTE HijacK