Scum need to claim something strong when pushed.

best claim? Town Doctor. Why?

Because to be counter claimed , it gives remaining mafia the route to the town doctor.

A claim from a desperate scum, for me. If he was town , he would have been hammered by now. The delay at L-1 says it all.

Vote stays with CSPVG

What if scum were already all on the wagon? Do you assume this was not so, and why?

I don't follow the logic. Could you please elaborate?

Actually the huge delay is between the 4rth and 5th vote. 18 hours if I'm not mistaken. Vitek unvoted about an hour after that, bringing the votes back to 4, and CSPVG's claim came soon after.

I have a problem with the question too, but whatever, I can wait for his reply.

Boy, am I slow!

I've been staring at the OP for almost a month now, trying to figure out what those names meant.

One finally dawned on me just now:

Iniurfas = In Your Face

Sorry for the diversion. Back to our main attraction.

EDIT:
4th, not 4rth.

LOL, I hadn't noticed the Iniurfas joke either.

Just don't, Rob.

Otherwise I am going to crash into nearby nebula.



Never got the joke, and wouldn't have. Would be funny if it was just coincidence.

People, if we won't get any counterclaim, then we are just not lynching him. It would be incredibly stupid.
And if he is scum and did it to lure true doctor out? Great for us, there will be only 1 scum left after this then. 1 PR for 1 mafia is almost always good trade and certainly would be in this situation.


For once in this game I am going to join you. That anxiety kills me.

I kind of agree with this actually. I thought we were past wanting to lynch CSPVG. I don't think the "potential real doctor" should claim at this point though.
BTW, someone needs to do a comparison of the wagons, Telika-style.
Hint: It won't be me since it would be too much work and it would "add nothing new to the discussion".



Have you considered the possibility that you hate me because you subconsciously hate JMich? Would it help if I channeled flub? It would probably be more fun for me. Wow such meta.

I can think of some very good reasons for a PRD (new acronym, I just coinified it) to claim. Why do you think the PRD shouldn't claim?

Survive another day, maybe save a townie? And if he dies during the Night we have his flip that we can use to lynch CSPVG.
Why, what are you thinking?

The thing he did in last post.
Attempt to lynch claimed doctor for the rest of game. Because it happened in the past. Doctor claimed on D1 and Rob spent 90% of remaining game trying to push for his lynch. I spent 3/4 of my strength in that game trying to dissuade him from it. After the doctor finaly died Rob apologised and talked about eating humble pie. And here we are again.

Please, do Joe. I would love you then. And you wold be forced to love me.


I can think of some as well but was is more importan about this post is that prd stands for fart in czech. ;-)

Actually, this would be adding something new, since you would be comparing and contrasting (hopefully) and not just listing the raw data. I only have problems with people listing data without drawing conclusions from it, then calling it 'scum-hunting'.

If I did Joe I'd vote myself.

I disagree. If a real doctor exists he must claim.
If CSPVG is false claiming we want to uncover it as soon as possible because every night he remains alive is a night he gets to use a mafia power role, if he has any.
As Vitek said, at this point a 1-for-1 trade is a bargain.