You are funny.

I said I would answer this , I've now got time...

First point - You make a direct reference to SPF saying about how we have lost the doctor and tell him 'don't worry' - don't worry why?? We have lost the Town doc, but you say 'Don't worry', yet you cant even see how that can be interpreted as a softclaim?? Why would you softclaim something like that? Of course, once its questioned there's denial. And your rebuttal is littered with inaccuracies - not once have I accused you of softclaiming Roleblocker - in fact in the very quote above I question SPF linking your words to Roleblocker - yet you accuse me in the very next sentence...
Why would you do it as scum? Hint at a role to make up for lost Town Doctor?...hmmm, let me think.....;)

SPF did indeed bring the first reference to it - and I think he tried a little too hard to backtrack on it.

Second Point - DarkoD13. Again , just look at my quote - I even say the fact i like his style has a condition - the condition being the manufactured spat between him and CSPVG...

Third point - its never bullshit on the first day. everyone is and should be a suspect - everyone except me is considered potential Mafia! But where do you get this bit about no-one should berate me for jumping at anyone???! berate me all you like - its part of the game!

Let me put it this way for you - it's first day. Not much to go on, so any slip will be magnified. You, to me, have made two. A very ill-judged 'joke' post that can only be considered some form of softclaim. Referring to Town as an outsider. Since then your aggressive defence has been full of bluster and not much substance.

Hmm, as much as my suspicion of Vitek is growing, Rob seems to be trying a little too hard to make Vitek's "softclaim" into more than it is.

I asked you to explain this before, how did I backtrack?

I...I...I...give up.
You are just too good for me.
I thought I was brilliant enough when I said "Don't worry I have a lot of make-up." to SirPrimalform (after his "...I hope we've got something to make up for that...") because I secretly advised him to claim role blocker during RVS as I knew he will have to claim soon in Day 1 and roleblocker is great claim when our doctor died in pre-game. Unfortunately for me, you saw right through it. On top of it, you are so far above me that it was obvious to you as you expected people to easily expose it ("Now I'm sorry, but theres no way on earth you can't see how that would give people pause - is it a softclaim? are you trying to attract attention?" - btw. while you haven't accused me of softclaiming roleblocking you accused me of softclaiming. I admit there is difference and I jumped the conclusion because that's what was previously mentioned by others and I couldn't see what other soft claim would you see there).
You got me here, there is nothing I can do to fight this back.




Are you even serious? Because now I doubt it.
Are you just trolling?



re:Darko; Still same. You like his posting even if it feels contrived. How can you like it if it feels contrived.


What aggressive defense I made? I would like to know as I was also accused of not defending myself.
Speaking of aggressive defense? Why would it make me scum? You accused me of it in every recent game we played and I was town every single time?

Your suspicion of me is rising based to post which connects us together us mafia? o_O
Does it mean your suspicion of you raises as well?
Because Rob's accusation doesn't work at all without us being scum team. Well, it doesn't work that way as well but it would work even less if it was possible. :-)

No, mine is based on the town slip thing.
I understand Rob's accusation, that's the reason I can dismiss it as bollocks so easily. As I said, he seems to be trying too hard to cook something up but it doesn't really work. If we were on the scum team, what exactly would I be achieving with my roleblocker comment? It makes no sense...

I'm pretty sure anyone who can can count would find eleven to be an odd number. *badum tshh*

More seriously it does make me wonder about the balancing. Since it seems unlikely we have one player who is 3/4 town and 1/4 mafia, I wonder whether we're dealing with a beefed up 2 person scum team, a weak 3 person team or a normal 3 person team with beefed up town? This speculation isn't tremendously helpful but I'm sleepy and on the bus and it has got me thinking about possible setups for a future game.

I am more thinking that, like last game, there is an 'invisible' player who may be acting through someone else. Maybe the captain of the ship, who may be neutral.

Oh, certainly. I'm the new kid on the block, and I don't know anyone. At all. My votes are cast at random, because I have no reason NOT to suspect anyone - and what may be construed as bandwagon-jumping is in fact me looking up to my virtual elders because it's a given they have a better idea of who is generally suspicious around here.

Right now the only person I know is not a mafioso is myself. Just your friendly neighborhood paranoid fella here, who also finds it highly disturbing that the guy that could save our lives was the first one to bite it.

As I say, your teammates aren't going to have a go at you for it.

I don't think you're saying
"They wouldn't even have noticed my softclaim if Sprimal hadn't..."

I think you're saying
"They wouldn't be having a go at me at all if Sprimal hadn't..."


-
I understand what Rob's saying
Not that the 'Make-Up' is the softclaim, responding to someone's worries about having dead doctor with "Don't worry X"
This hadn't occurred to me (or, if it had occurred to me, I have since forgotten all about it) and I suppose it makes sense.
So that later on you could falseclaim some sort of protective role and say "see? I've been seeding you clues from the beginning so it must be genuine."
And if you come up with a better falseclaim, well you just ignore it.

It's possible. I don't know.

-
11 players? We'll find out eventually. Just makes a nice change, I reckon.

ho hum...

New idea, I have read too many Agatha Christie books. The doctor is the 12'th invisible player. He did not really die (there is not body), he is just hiding.

That was my thought too. If anyone finds the body, shoot him once in the head to make sure he's dead... :D

CSPVG asked you to explain your vote and I see no explaantion here.

@CSPVG; I suspect it could be 2+1 (2mafia + 1SK) setup but it can be anything. Although it's weird, speculating about it helps us in no way right now.

@Joe; Have you, in any game we played together, ever, at laast once considered me to be not mafia aligned? :-)


OT: I was able to read this thread by reading different. It was white, I even had reply here, but I read other thread first and when I returned to General Discussion this thread was already gray and without reply.

I hope he won't return. We have enough to worry about even without bloated zombie running around.

"And, as his blood on the ship's rail has been carefully wiped off and his body immerged miles ago,..."