Posted November 07, 2011
so correct me if im wrong Rodzaju is implying that bazilisek is a doctor with a variation sutch as a Insane Doctor or Naïve Doctor if so how would he know that?
Cruward_Darkeyes
the half orc
Registered: Sep 2011
From Australia
Rodzaju
Official Bastard
Registered: Jan 2010
From United Kingdom
Posted November 07, 2011
That started out as a (i thought) fairly harmless attempt to get things moving.
I guess I should have learned...
If he won't get counter-claimed soon we can presume baz is mooost likely not lying.
I just know things about people.
Things that I believe they don't know about themselves.
Baz is not lying, but it seems that he doesn't know everything....
Cruward_Darkeyes
the half orc
Registered: Sep 2011
From Australia
Posted November 07, 2011
That started out as a (i thought) fairly harmless attempt to get things moving.
I guess I should have learned...
your confusing the hell out of me
If he won't get counter-claimed soon we can presume baz is mooost likely not lying.
I just know things about people.
Things that I believe they don't know about themselves.
Baz is not lying, but it seems that he doesn't know everything....
Rodzaju
Official Bastard
Registered: Jan 2010
From United Kingdom
JoeSapphire
Consultant Liar
Registered: Jun 2011
From United Kingdom
Posted November 07, 2011
Oooh my mister Darkeyes! You need to read the mafia wiki or get the mod to give you a more throrough outline of the game.
PREEDIT - yeah you've had it explained by five other people and you've read all about it on the wiki but I'll leave it in anyway
Doctors are a basic role in mafia games - at night they pick a player to protect and that player won't die if someone tries to kill them. They are usually town, but in setups with more than one mafia family there can be a mafia doctor. Does your flavour leave any doubt as to Bazil's alignment Zaju?
As I see it Rodzaju referring to the Town WAS meaningless and IS meaningless. At the time it was the hot topic of the day, and Robbeasy was asking people for their opinions on it - mine was that it was meaningless.
Lynching people for very little reason is dangerous so pointing out flawed logic is in the interests of the town. (I use the phrase "the town" here, as my sentiments are generic and don't refer solely to this game)
I still think we should ignore both Bazilisek and Rodzaju and see what the night can reveal to us. There will be time to lynch them later, when it might be more apparent whether or not they're lying.
I'm inclined to believe we have two true claims here.
Lynching either of them just because they are the ones who have all eyes on them would be a mistake - there is more can be done this day (but maybe no more people claim eh?)
Is that you there Vitek? Subtly calling for a counter claim? Yeah I thought it was. Vote Vitek
PREEDIT - yeah you've had it explained by five other people and you've read all about it on the wiki but I'll leave it in anyway
Doctors are a basic role in mafia games - at night they pick a player to protect and that player won't die if someone tries to kill them. They are usually town, but in setups with more than one mafia family there can be a mafia doctor. Does your flavour leave any doubt as to Bazil's alignment Zaju?
As I see it Rodzaju referring to the Town WAS meaningless and IS meaningless. At the time it was the hot topic of the day, and Robbeasy was asking people for their opinions on it - mine was that it was meaningless.
Lynching people for very little reason is dangerous so pointing out flawed logic is in the interests of the town. (I use the phrase "the town" here, as my sentiments are generic and don't refer solely to this game)
I still think we should ignore both Bazilisek and Rodzaju and see what the night can reveal to us. There will be time to lynch them later, when it might be more apparent whether or not they're lying.
I'm inclined to believe we have two true claims here.
Lynching either of them just because they are the ones who have all eyes on them would be a mistake - there is more can be done this day (but maybe no more people claim eh?)
Is that you there Vitek? Subtly calling for a counter claim? Yeah I thought it was. Vote Vitek
Cruward_Darkeyes
the half orc
Registered: Sep 2011
From Australia
Posted November 07, 2011
uhh woops i kinda messd up my last post sorry for being a noob anyway i was saying Rodzaju is confusing me a whole but tone
JoeSapphire: Oooh my mister Darkeyes! You need to read the mafia wiki or get the mod to give you a more throrough outline of the game.
PREEDIT - yeah you've had it explained by five other people and you've read all about it on the wiki but I'll leave it in anyway
Doctors are a basic role in mafia games - at night they pick a player to protect and that player won't die if someone tries to kill them. They are usually town, but in setups with more than one mafia family there can be a mafia doctor. Does your flavour leave any doubt as to Bazil's alignment Zaju?
As I see it Rodzaju referring to the Town WAS meaningless and IS meaningless. At the time it was the hot topic of the day, and Robbeasy was asking people for their opinions on it - mine was that it was meaningless.
Lynching people for very little reason is dangerous so pointing out flawed logic is in the interests of the town. (I use the phrase "the town" here, as my sentiments are generic and don't refer solely to this game)
I still think we should ignore both Bazilisek and Rodzaju and see what the night can reveal to us. There will be time to lynch them later, when it might be more apparent whether or not they're lying.
I'm inclined to believe we have two true claims here.
Lynching either of them just because they are the ones who have all eyes on them would be a mistake - there is more can be done this day (but maybe no more people claim eh?)
Is that you there Vitek? Subtly calling for a counter claim? Yeah I thought it was. Vote Vitek yeah sorry im brand new to this and iv been lurking heaps and i figured it was time i tryd to actually do something even if i didn't fully understand all that was going on
PREEDIT - yeah you've had it explained by five other people and you've read all about it on the wiki but I'll leave it in anyway
Doctors are a basic role in mafia games - at night they pick a player to protect and that player won't die if someone tries to kill them. They are usually town, but in setups with more than one mafia family there can be a mafia doctor. Does your flavour leave any doubt as to Bazil's alignment Zaju?
As I see it Rodzaju referring to the Town WAS meaningless and IS meaningless. At the time it was the hot topic of the day, and Robbeasy was asking people for their opinions on it - mine was that it was meaningless.
Lynching people for very little reason is dangerous so pointing out flawed logic is in the interests of the town. (I use the phrase "the town" here, as my sentiments are generic and don't refer solely to this game)
I still think we should ignore both Bazilisek and Rodzaju and see what the night can reveal to us. There will be time to lynch them later, when it might be more apparent whether or not they're lying.
I'm inclined to believe we have two true claims here.
Lynching either of them just because they are the ones who have all eyes on them would be a mistake - there is more can be done this day (but maybe no more people claim eh?)
Is that you there Vitek? Subtly calling for a counter claim? Yeah I thought it was. Vote Vitek
Post edited November 07, 2011 by Cruward_Darkeyes
JoeSapphire
Consultant Liar
Registered: Jun 2011
From United Kingdom
Posted November 07, 2011
Ah you can't post twice in succession like that! Leave ten minutes between each post or it marks it as edited and we can't tell if you've deleted something!
bazilisek
gone
Registered: Oct 2009
From Czech Republic
Posted November 07, 2011
If you're right, then the only excuse, and I do mean the only excuse I would accept for outing me for no reason at all would be if I am one of them quack doctors, and as such basically useless. The flavour I have, however, does not really agree with that. I'm tired and overworked, yes, but I am an experienced medical practitioner.
Rodzaju
Official Bastard
Registered: Jan 2010
From United Kingdom
Posted November 07, 2011
I just know things about people.
Things that I believe they don't know about themselves.
Baz is not lying, but it seems that he doesn't know everything....
Overworked....
Stressed.....
Maybe a bit rushed & not careful enough, or maybe too careful & getting in your own way...
JoeSapphire
Consultant Liar
Registered: Jun 2011
From United Kingdom
Posted November 07, 2011
Is this really helpful?
and I forgot to unvote before so Unvote Orryyrro. Hopefully that won't cause a problem.
and I forgot to unvote before so Unvote Orryyrro. Hopefully that won't cause a problem.
bazilisek
gone
Registered: Oct 2009
From Czech Republic
Posted November 07, 2011
Overworked....
Stressed.....
Maybe a bit rushed & not careful enough, or maybe too careful & getting in your own way...
I don't know. But we're too far gone down this particular rabbit hole to ignore it, don't you think?
Cruward_Darkeyes
the half orc
Registered: Sep 2011
From Australia
Posted November 07, 2011
Overworked....
Stressed.....
Maybe a bit rushed & not careful enough, or maybe too careful & getting in your own way...
Vitek
Master of Karate and friendship for everyone
Registered: Apr 2009
From British Indian Ocean Territory
Rodzaju
Official Bastard
Registered: Jan 2010
From United Kingdom
Posted November 07, 2011
JoeSapphire
Consultant Liar
Registered: Jun 2011
From United Kingdom
Posted November 07, 2011
So we're trying to guess his thing. Is he a paranoid doctor IE jailkeeper?
We suspect that there are multiple mafia families, and we're pretty certain that Bazil is a modified doctor - it's a fair possibility we have more than one doctor anyway so it might not be counterclaiming it could just be mass claiming which I imagine to be a bad idea on the first day.
We suspect that there are multiple mafia families, and we're pretty certain that Bazil is a modified doctor - it's a fair possibility we have more than one doctor anyway so it might not be counterclaiming it could just be mass claiming which I imagine to be a bad idea on the first day.