Fenixp: Eh... Check your spoiler tags ;-)
*Spoilers*
So anyway, slaughtering elves was for the survival of another race, which arguably had as much right of survival as the elves did. Yes, there was a way of weaseling out of it in another way, but that's unimportant right now. When it comes to killing of Alistair, the argument for his death was that his very existence could have disastrous effects on entire Ferelden. Sure, you could spin those to be evil - but none of those decisions were inherently evil. Decisions like that existed in Dragon Age II and I'm sure they'll be in Inquisition as well, it's just none of those games were exactly written with the concept of good and evil in mind.
I disagree completely.
The survival of another race? We're talking about a small group of humans here, and you don't even have to work hard for a scenario in which both the elves and the werewolves survive. You are able to make an informed decision, and there is no rational reason to choose anything else. I still chose to slaughter the elves because I wanted to. And that is evil, because I say it is!
I had Alistair executed because I hated him and wanted him dead! Anora's motivation is simply the "official version" that just happened to serve my needs.
My Warden was a selfish genocidal villain, and I loved the game for that. It gave my character, well....character. All the Inquisition videos I have seen so far merely give the player character responses that are...neutral, non-committal even. In that way, the Inquisitor seems to have even less personality than Shepard or Hawke, if that is even possible.